- Research article
- Open Access
Effect of SDF-1 with biphasic ceramic-like bone graft on the repair of rabbit radial defect
Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research volume 14, Article number: 231 (2019)
This study aimed to investigate the effects of stromal cell-derived factor-1 (SDF-1) on biphasic ceramic-like biologic bone (BCBB) in vivo on the repair of large segment bone defect in rabbits.
A large-segment radius defect model of the rabbits was constructed. In the experimental group, BCBB with SDF-1 sustained-release system were implanted into the bone defect site. Other three groups including normal control, autologous bone graft, and BCBB implantation without SDF-1 were set. After surgery, general observation, X-ray radiography and scoring, and tissue section staining were performed at 2, 4, 8, 12, and 24 weeks post-implantation.
By general observation, X-ray radiography and grading and tissue section staining observation, we found that the BCBB carrying SDF-1 was better than those in the group of BCBB without SDF-1 (P < 0.05). BCBB scaffold had certain bone conduction capacity, and the BCBB scaffold carrying SDF-1 had improved bone conduction ability and possessed bone induction ability. In the case of carrying SDF-1, it can be used to repair large bone defects in a shorter time than simply using BCBB, which is equivalent to the effect of autologous bone.
BCBB scaffold carrying SDF-1 can promote the repair effect on a large bone defect, which is equivalent to the effect of autologous bone.
Bone graft substitute materials are used by orthopedic surgeons to promote bone formation and repair bone defects [1, 2]. Compared with autologous bone materials and allogeneic bone materials, xenogeneic bone-derived implants have advantages such as wide sources, easy tissue preparation, and economic properties . However, there are also potential disease transmission and common defects such as graft immune rejection . Therefore, the xenograft bone should be treated with physical and chemical processing before use to minimize risks and to substantially decrease antigenicity [3, 5]. The ceramic-like xenogeneic bone formed by appropriate physical and chemical treatment and low-temperature calcination has a natural reticulated pore structure , and its main component is hydroxyapatite (HAP), while HAP is a slow-absorbing ceramic with poor biodegradability . Therefore, it is often necessary to modify or compound with other materials to accelerate its absorption. At present, biologically derived materials related to bovine bone source have been developed and extensively studied [8, 9]. Lin et al. used the method of adding two sodium bovine calcinations and adding sodium pyrophosphate solution to convert HAP into tricalcium phosphate (TCP) with better degradation performance .
A previous study showed that after specific physical and chemical treatment of the pig cancellous bone, they prepared biphasic ceramic-like biologic bone (BCBB) mainly containing HAP and TCP, showing the certain osteogenic effect on the repair of radial bone defect model in animals . It was found that this bone-derived BCBB of pig also had good biocompatibility and bone conduction ability . In terms of physical and chemical properties, mineral inorganic salt Ca, P, organic protein content, and porosity of BCBB are similar to the human bone . Therefore, BCBB can also be used as a heterogeneous bone-derived material with great potential, which is worthy of further research and exploration.
The chemokine stromal cell-derived factor-1 (SDF-1) has been widely investigated for its characteristic of homing bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) to the site of injury and inflammation [12, 13]. MSCs have been found to be responsible for tissue repair and immunological disorders by migration to the injury and inflammation in response to SDF-1 . The SDF-1/CXCR4 axis is the most important chemotactic homing pathway on the surface of bone MSCs, and it is also the most widely used signal pathway in osteogenesis-related research . The BCBB itself has a certain bone conduction capacity, and we speculate that the combination of BCBB and SDF-1 can achieve the effect of bone repair.
Currently, no other growth factors have been reported to possess the chemotaxis effect of bone MSC homing, comparable to SDF-1. Thus, in this study, the effect of carrying SDF-1 on repairing a large bone defect of BCBB was explored. Porcine bone was used as a raw material to prepare non-immunogenic BCBB by physicochemical processing. We expected that our findings could provide an animal experimental basis for clinical application in the future.
Forty 3-month-old healthy Japanese big-ear white rabbits of either gender (weighing 2–2.5 kg) and four 8-month-old healthy Diannan small-ear pigs of either gender (weighing 20 kg) were purchased from the Experimental Animal Center Department of Laboratory Animal Science, Kunming Medical University (Kunming, China).
All animal experimental procedures were approved by the Ethics Committee of Kunming Medical University.
Preparation of SDF-1 sustained-release system
The commercially available chitosan (CS; 100 μg; Adamas Reagent Co., Ltd., Shanghai, China), 50 μl of 1% acetic acid solution, and 4850 μl of double distilled water were added to a 50-ml beaker to prepare a CS buffer solution. The beaker was covered with tin foil paper, and the CS was completely dissolved by stirring at low speed for 2 h at 200 rpm on a magnetic stirrer at room temperature. Then, 2 μg of SDF-1 (PeproTech Inc., Rocky Hill, New Jersey, USA) was added into the CS slow-release solution; and the mixture was stirred at a low speed of 200 rpm for another 2 h on the magnetic stirrer to obtain a CS/SDF-1 sustained-release system.
Preparation of BCBB
This process was performed as previously described by Xiu et al.  with modifications. In brief, all the procedures were carried out under sterile conditions. The femur and tibia of Diannan small-ear pigs were washed and disinfected, and the bone saw was also disinfected. The femur was cut horizontally with the bone saw at the lesser trochanter. The femur was cut horizontally with the bone saw on the medial and lateral iliac crests below the femur, and the femur in the middle of the femur was discarded, leaving the greater trochanter, lesser trochanter, and medial and lateral iliac crest. In addition, the tibia was cut horizontally with the bone saw at the tibial trochanter, and the lower part of the tibia was discarded, leaving the upper part. Subsequently, the femur and tibia bones were cut into 0.5-cm thick bone pieces in the horizontal direction with the bone saw. The cortical bone was removed along the edge of the bone with the bone saw. The cancellous bone piece from which the cortical bone was removed was sawed into a 1.5 cm × 0.5 cm × 0.5 cm cuboid bone piece with the bone saw. Then, the bone pieces were put into a 500-ml beaker which was added with a small amount of double distilled water and then boiled for 6 h; then, the cancellous bone pieces were put into a porcelain boat that was subsequently put into a desiccator (Dafeng Laboratory Equipment Co., Ltd., Shanghai, China) for overnight. The porcelain boat with cancellous bone pieces was put into a muffle furnace (Luoyang Liyu Furnace Co., Ltd., China) and raised to 800 °C at 10 °C/min and held for 1 h.
The calcined cancellous bone pieces were then soaked with 0.04 mol/ml sodium pyrophosphate solution in a glass test tube, being ultrasonically vibrated at 40 KHz for 30 min and let the sodium pyrophosphate solution entering the cancellous bone void. After that, the cancellous bone was put into the porcelain boat which was then put into the desiccator overnight. The porcelain boat with the cancellous bone was put into the muffle furnace and raised to 1150 °C at 10 °C/min and held for 1 h to obtain BCBB. After cooling, the BCBB was put in the desiccator and prepared for use.
SDF-1 loading onto BCBB
All the procedures were carried out under sterile conditions. The BCBB was taken out of the desiccator and placed into a glass test tube with CS/SDF-1 slow-release solution to ensure that the BCBB was completely immersed in the CS/SDF-1 sustained-release solution. The glass tube mouth was sealed with sealing glue, and the tube was ultrasonically vibrated at 40 KHz for 30 min, so that CS/SDF-1 slow-release system was loaded on the inner wall of BCBB void. The BCBB was removed from the glass test tube with sterile forceps and placed on an aseptic table to dry at room temperature. After drying, the BCBB was transferred into a 2-ml centrifuge tube that was then sealed and put into the desiccator for later use.
Radius defect model in rabbits
The 40 healthy Japanese big-ear white rabbits were randomly divided into A (blank group), B (autologous bone group), C (BCBB group), and D (SDF-1/BCBB) groups (n = 10 in each group). All the procedures were performed under strict aseptic conditions. Rabbits in each group were anesthetized by an intraperitoneal injection of 10% chloral hydrate (3 ml/kg). After anesthesia, the rabbit was fixed on the operating table of the animal, and the rabbits’ fur was excised from the front limb, and the surgical site was exposed, followed by disinfection. A 1.5-cm incision in the middle part of the radius of the forelimb was made using a scalpel, and the tissue overlying the mid-shaft of the radius dissected. The periosteum of the bone surface was peeled off with a periosteal stripper, and a scalpel was used to mark about 0.8 cm at both ends of the midline of the radius. The length of the bone section was measured with a stainless steel ruler to ensure a 1.5-cm radius defect (Fig. 1a). In the marked position of the scalpel, the bone puncture needle was used for grinding, the bone was slowly cut off along the grinding place with the bone nippers, and the broken end was ground down with the bone file. The length of the bone that removed was about 1.5 cm (Fig. 1b).
The surgical field was rinsed with hydrogen peroxide and iodine volt. The radial bone was removed after bilateral radial truncation in group A. Group B was implanted with autologous contralateral radius on both sides. Group C was implanted bilaterally with BCBB. Group D was implanted bilaterally with BCBB/SDF-1, and the implantation of the implant was ensured. The incision was sutured layer by layer; the skin was sutured intermittently and covered with sterile gauze. Daily intramuscular injection of 400,000 units of penicillin was performed 3 days after the operation to prevent wound infection, and then, the penicillin was used once every other day to observe the wound healing.
The surgical site, activities, and eating status of the animals in each group were observed postoperatively. Two rabbits of group A, B, C, and D were sacrificed by air embolism at 2, 4, 8, 12, and 24 weeks postoperatively to observe the wound healing, changes of implants, and the relationship between implants and the surrounding bone and tissue.
Two rabbits in groups A, B, C, and D were sacrificed at 2, 4, 8, 12, and 24 weeks postoperatively. The orthotopic X-ray of the ulna and radius of the forelimb were photographed to detect the repair effect of large segmental bone defects. X-ray films were scored according to Lane-Sandhu grading ; the scores were statistically analyzed using SPSS.17.0.
Two rabbits of groups A, B, C, and D were sacrificed at 2, 4, 8, 12, and 24 weeks postoperatively. The radius was cut at 0.5 cm at both ends of the implant, and the specimen was completely intercepted and fixed with 75% ethanol for 15 days. After soaking in 85% alcohol for 12 h, 90% alcohol for 24 h, 95% alcohol for 24 h, absolute ethanol for 24 h, and pure toluene for 6 h for gradient dehydration, the specimen was put into the embedded container with a few block copolymers of poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) and then PMMA prepolymer solution was added, followed by vacuuming for 5 h, so that there was no bubble in the specimen. The embedding container was completely enclosed and let it stand in the refrigerator at 4 °C for 14 days. Polymerization was done at room temperature until PMMA was fully hardened. The fixed gross specimen was put into the low-speed precision cutting machine, and the cutting thickness was adjusted to 150 mm for slicing. Then, 1 ml of polylysine was added to the slides, and the sections were attached to a glass slide and fixed by extrusion for 24 h, and air bubbles were discharged. The sections were polished to 50 μm for subsequent use.
The sections were stained with Van Gieson and hematoxylin-eosin (H&E) stains according to standard protocols. The histological observation was performed using an Olympus microscope (Olympus, Tokyo, Japan).
Measurement of bone area
Two slices were randomly selected from group B, C, and D, respectively. Two fields of view at both ends and middle part of the bone defect were taken; a total of 12 visual fields were measured using a phase contrast microscope (BX53; Olympus, Tokyo, Japan) under × 40 magnifications. The bone areas were calculated with the histogram function of Photoshop 11.0 software [17, 18].
All experimental data were represented as mean ± standard deviation (SD). One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to analyze the results of multiple groups of statistical data using SPSS 17.0, and t test was performed between two groups. P < 0.05 was statistically significant.
The obtained BCBB is pale, ceramic-like, with a large number of pores visible on the surface (Fig. 1c). The BCBB/SDF-1 composite bone was yellowish in color and had a large amount of pores filled with CS/SDF-1 (Fig. 1d).
On the first day after the operation, the animals were able to move and eat normally, and there was no obvious exudation at the wound which was wrapped with gauze. At the time of dressing change, scabs were visible and healed well. Within 1 week after surgery, the forearm was slightly swollen compared to the healthy side and gradually subsided 3 days later. Two weeks after the operation, a part of the scab exfoliated and the skin healed well. The hair growth at the surgical site 1 month after the operation was not significantly different from the surrounding non-surgical area, and the skin scar was not obvious. No sign of surgical site infection was found during the experiment.
Observation at 2 weeks after operation
In each group, the fracture ends of the bone were visible. A large amount of tissue fluid exudation and new tissue formation occurred in the fracture ends of group A. A large number of new fiber-like tissues were seen in the gap between autologous bone and host bone in group B. The BCBB materials in group C and group D were clear, and there was tissue growth in the space between the materials (Fig. 2).
Observation at 4 weeks after operation
In group A, the exudation was reduced, the medullary cavity was closed by fibrous tissue, and the surrounding tissue formed fibrotic adhesion. In group B, new fibrous callus wrapped around the broken end of the bone and periosteum-like tissue was found on the surface of the autogenous bone. In group C, the surface of the material was intact, closely bound with the host bone tissue, and the new callus wrapped around the surface of the material. In group D, the surface structure of the material was intact, tightly bound to the host bone, forming new callus around and abundant blood supply (Fig. 2).
Observation at 8 weeks after operation
In group A, bone fractured ends were closed, and a large number of fibrous tissues were wrapped, which made it difficult to separate from the surrounding tissues and muscles, and fibrous scars were formed. In group B, the autogenous bone and host bone formed bone healing, callus growth was obvious, and bone graft was absorbed and remodeled. The material of group C was complete and tightly bound to the host bone, the surface and pores of the material were filled with tissues, and the BCBB material was absorbed and degraded to different extents. The BCBB material structure of group D was relatively complete, with a large number of calluses forming on the surface and the material is closely bound to the host bone, with the material absorption, and the repair section had a good shape (Fig. 2).
Observation at 12 weeks after operation
In group A, bone resorption occurred at the defect site, and the surrounding fibrous tissue formed scar adhesion. In group B, the autogenous bone was completely fused with the host bone, and the surface of the bone was covered with periosteum-like tissue, and the blood supply was abundant; in group C, the graft materials of group C were not clearly separated from bone tissue, forming a firm union, and the repair segment was well shaped. In group D, the material and bone formed a firm union with unclear boundaries, graft materials were absorbed, and the shape of some was close to the normal radius bone (Fig. 2).
Observation at 24 weeks after operation
There was no significant difference between the visual observation at 24 weeks and 12 weeks in group A. The shape of group B at 24 weeks was similar to the radius. In group C, the surface of tissue was packed tightly, the blood supply was abundant, the boundary between the bone tissue and the host bone was unclear, and the repair segment had a good shape. The repaired segment of group D was well shaped and showed no obvious difference from the host bone shape (Fig. 2).
In group A, the bright zone of the bone defect was observed at every time point. At 2 weeks, the bone defect was obvious and transparent, the fibrous tissue was filled, the fracture margin was neat, and the medullary cavity was connected with the outside. At 4 weeks, a small amount of bone absorption and remodeling appeared at the fracture end, and the fibrous tissue filled the defect area and filled the medullary cavity. At 8 weeks, the bone absorption and remodeling at the fracture end was obvious, the bone absorption at the proximal ulnar side was less, and the bone absorption at the distal ulna side was more; high smoothness and brightness at the broken end was found, the fibrous scar was filled in the defect area, and the medullary cavity was closed. At 12 weeks, the bone cortex of the fracture end was hardened and smooth, and the X-ray changes were not obvious at 24 and 12 weeks (Fig. 3).
In group B, at 2 weeks, the interspace between the broken end and the implanted bone was clear, the medullary cavity was exposed, and the fibrous tissue was proliferated. At 4 weeks, the fibrous tissue was proliferated in the interspace between the broken end and the implanted bone, the boundary between the autogenous bone and the broken bone was blurred, and a small amount of proliferative bone-like tissue was filled in the medullary cavity of the broken bone. At 8 weeks, the bone and the implanted bone formed a bone connection, and the bone cortex was thickened at the bone junction, the fibrous tissue was wrapped, and the medullary cavity structure was formed. At 12 weeks, the broken end of the bone was continuous with the implanted bone cortex, and the medullary cavity was connected, the brightness of the cortical bone was increased at the junction, and the shape was rough. At 24 weeks, the bone cortex was continuous and intact, and the medullary cavity was reconstructed. There is no difference with the normal radius (Fig. 3).
In group C, at 2 weeks, the implanted BCBB graft material was well aligned with the fracture end without obvious displacement, the material was in complete shape, the internal pore structure was clear, the gap between the fracture end and the host bone was clearly visible, and the medullary cavity was exposed without obvious callus growth. At 4 weeks, the broken end bone showed different degrees of absorption and remodeling, the edge of the implanted material was slightly blurred, and the general structure was complete. The surrounding hyperplastic fibrous tissue was wrapped around it. At the 8th week, the edge of the implant material showed different degrees of degradation and absorption, the broken end of the marrow cavity was not closed, and bone callus filled the cavity. At 12 weeks, the density of graft materials increased, showing a high-brightness shadow, which was similar to the density of radius, and partly surrounded the new bone. At 24 weeks, the graft material density increased, the density of the connection site was similar to that of the radius, the morphology became narrower, and the connection was close to the bone (Fig. 3).
In group D, at 2 weeks, the implants were well aligned with the broken ends, without obvious displacement, with clear pore structure, clear space between the broken ends and the host bone, and exposure of the medullary cavity. At 4 weeks, the material had a complete appearance, the density of the contact surface with the broken bone was increased, the bone was remodeled, and the material was covered by the bone callus. At 8 weeks, the graft and the host bone were not clearly separated, the density was similar to the host bone, the pore structure in the graft was not clear, and the medullary cavity was not closed. At 12 weeks, the graft material was partially absorbed, shortened, and narrowed, and bone healing was shown at the fracture end, the density of repaired area was similar to that of radius, and the boundary was unclear. At 24 weeks, the medullary cavity was reconstructed. The cortex of the repaired area was continuous and smooth, similar to that of the radius, and the density of the medullary cavity was slightly higher, which was the residual shadow of the material (Fig. 3).
The X-rays were scored according to the X-ray scoring standard of Lane et al. . The evaluation contents were three parts: the healing of the graft and the host bone, the formation of the marrow cavity, and the degree of reconstruction of the bone marrow cavity. The results showed that there were differences between group B and group C at 8, 12, and 24 weeks (P < 0.05). There was a difference between group B and group D at 8 weeks (P < 0.05). There was a difference between group C and group D at 24 weeks (P < 0.05). The B group had the best bone defect repair effect, the D group was the second, and the C group was the worst. There was no significant difference in the X-ray results of the bone repair between group B and group D after 12 weeks (Table 1).
Van Gieson staining
At 2 weeks, the fractured ends of each group were obvious. In group A, the fractured ends were neat, the surrounding fibrous tissue proliferated, the cells infiltrated, and the multinucleated cells were seen around the broken ends of the bone, which were involved in bone resorption. No obvious inflammatory cell infiltration was observed. In group B, the fibrous tissue was connected between the autologous bone and the host bone. A large number of cells infiltrated without obvious inflammatory cell infiltration. In group C, the new blood vessels and fibrous tissue grew into the graft material, less than group D; bone fracture ends are neat without inflammatory cell infiltration. In group D, new blood vessels and fibrous tissues grew into the material, and a large number of cells were infiltrated, without inflammatory cell infiltration (Fig. 4).
At 4 weeks, the bone around the broken end of group A was absorbed and remodeled, and the medullary cavity was gradually closed. The autologous bone of group B was tightly bound to the host bone, and there were a large number of the fibrous callus mixed with red-stained bone callus. In group C, more blood vessels and fibrous tissue grew into the graft material and a small amount of bone formation occurred, and fibrous tissue connection between the material and host bone was observed (Fig. 5). More blood vessels and fibrous tissue in the D group grew into the graft material (Fig. 5), the new bone tissue was seen in the graft material, and the collagen was distributed along the surface of the material (Fig. 4).
At 8 weeks, in group A, the bone trabeculae of broken ends had a clear texture, and the bone trabeculae in bone resorption and remodeling areas were disordered. In group B, the autologous bone marrow cavity was recanalized. The texture of the new trabecular bone was not well arranged, which was distinct from the host bone. Osteoblasts formed blue-stained collagen on the surface of the graft material and red-stained bone-like tissue appeared on the surface of the material. In group C, formed bone cells formed blue-stained collagen on the surface of the material (Fig. 5). In group D, new bone increased and gradually grew from both ends of the defect. Red staining bone tissue appeared in the graft material (Fig. 5). The osteoblast cells were large and dark in color, and the mesenchymal nuclei were shallow, and many protrusions were distributed along the edge of the material (Fig. 4).
At 12 weeks, in group A, the medullary cavity was closed and the bone was continuous. In group B, the autologous bone marrow cavity was recanalized. The medullary cavity was absorbed and reconstructed, and the trabecular bone texture was regular in the repaired area. In group C, the red staining bone tissue was increased along the material surface, the blood vessels were increased, and there was collagen deposition around the blood vessels. In group D, new bones are increased, the graft material space decreased, the trabecular arrangement of new bone was disordered, the cellular osteogenesis was active, and the graft material was bonded to the new bone.
At 24 weeks, in group A, the aggregation of polynuclear cells was found along the sclerotin in the medullary cavity side, bone resorption and remodeling was found, and bone trabecula texture was observed. In group B, the cortical bone structure was clear and trabecular bone was arranged regularly. In group C, the graft material occupied space was reduced and filled with new bone tissue (shown by the green arrow), and the bone binding between the material and new bone tissue (shown by the black arrow) was more disorderly. All materials in group D were absorbed, the new bone trabeculae were arranged in order, calcification was good (shown by the green arrow), the medullary cavity was reconstructed, and there was occasional residual material degradation outside the bone cortex of the lateral medullary cavity.
Measurement of bone area
There were differences in bone formation at the same time point (P < 0.05) in each group, with B group constituting the most bone formation, followed by D group, and C group the least. There was no significant difference in bone formation between group C and group D before 4 weeks (P > 0.05), and all of them were less than group B. After 8 weeks, the bone formation in D was more than that in group C (P < 0.05), and there was no significant difference between group B and D after 12 weeks (P > 0.05). It can be considered that the final bone formation effect of group D was equivalent to that of group B and significantly superior to group C (Fig. 5b, Table 2).
Among ceramic materials, TCP and HAP are two important components. HA is not easy to degrade but plays an important role in material stability and compressive capacity . TCP reflects the strength and weakness of material biodegradation . The ideal HA/TCP hybrid material can ensure that the material is firm and not deformed during the repair process, provide climbing effect for cell growth, and also take into account the growth of new tissue, without interference to the repair process, and ultimately not cause delayed healing or malformed healing. Lin et al. successfully reduced the high content of HA in the bovine bone by two calcinations and the addition of pyrophosphate and increased the TCP content . On this basis, Xiu et al. applied it to pig bones and successfully prepared BCBB containing mainly TCP and HAP and confirmed its good cell compatibility . Calcium sulfate (CS) is widely used as a bone graft binder and expander, which exhibits weak acidity after dissolution . The weakly acidic environment is not conducive to cell growth, and this property is changed by physical and chemical treatment or addition of ions and functional groups, which increases the difficulty of operation and increases the production cost. BCBB solves this problem. In the body, BCBB materials can release a large amount of Ca+, P plasma, and related groups when they degrade, forming a slightly alkaline environment around the material, which can neutralize the slightly acidic environment formed by CS degradation .
In the present study, from the perspective of the repair process in animal experiments, the existence of SDF-1 accelerates the whole process of bone defect repair, achieving the goal of earlier repair and faster recovery, and the final repair effect is equivalent to the “gold standard” autologous bone no matter in X-ray performance, X-ray score, or new bone mass analysis, and satisfactory results were obtained. SDF-1 increases the local blood supply by promoting angiogenesis in the graft material , providing channels and nutrients for seed cell homing and proliferation, and promoting osteogenic differentiation by inducing MSCs to upregulate the expression of BMP-related proteins. For the osteoblasts that have been differentiated, it can enhance the osteogenesis by upregulating the expression of factors such as alkaline phosphatase and osteocalcin in the cells , while strengthening the BCBB-limited bone conduction ability at the same time, with good ability of bone induction. According to the results of tissue section in group D, in addition to the appearance of endochondral ossification, there was also an endochondral ossification trend at the graft material-tissue interface, which effectively proved that SDF-1 enhanced the osteogenesis effect of osteoblasts attached to the material surface. In addition, CS promotes chemotaxis of osteoprogenitor cells and promotes adhesion to promote final osteogenesis , and alkaline environment contributes to a cell differentiation , which provides an effective support for the enhancement of osteogenesis by SDF-1/BCBB scaffold, indicating that BCBB carrying SDF-1 has good bone repair ability.
MSCs as the basic cellular unit of embryologic bone formation are required for bone generation, bone repair, and remodeling . MSC implantation has been widely applied for bone regeneration, bone repair, and metabolic bone disease in the clinic [28, 29]. SDF-1 is an important chemokine for recruitment and entrapment of MSCs . In the present study, SDF-1 promoted the large bone repairment after BCBB scaffold implantation in rabbit models. Our findings may provide the basis of the application of SDF-1 in bone repairment, which could save the time for purification and culture-expandation of human MSCs.
Although a significant effect of SDF-1 on bone repairment after the bone graft has been found, there are some limitations in the present study. Firstly, the bone area was observed to evaluate the number of homing MSCs indirectly. The quantitative analysis of homing MSCs was not performed. Secondly, the effect of SDF1 on MSCs migration in vitro and homing in vivo with the application of SDF1 sustained-release system was not investigated. The related experiments are warranted in the near future.
In conclusion, our study found that BCBB scaffold had a certain bone conduction capacity, and the BCBB scaffold carrying SDF-1 had improved bone conduction ability and possessed bone induction ability. In the case of carrying SDF-1, it can be used to repair large bone defects in a shorter time than simply using BCBB, and the ultimate repair effect of large bone defects is equivalent to that of autologous bone. However, there are still many problems to be studied and solved before clinical application. It is believed that this new bone tissue engineering scaffold can provide promising candidate treatment of bone injury with SDF-1 in the clinic.
Availability of data and materials
All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article.
Biphasic ceramic-like biologic bone
Marrow mesenchymal stem cells
Stromal cell-derived factor-1
Wang W, Yeung KWK. Bone grafts and biomaterials substitutes for bone defect repair: a review. Bioact Mater. 2017;2(4):224–47 [Review].
Shegarfi H, Reikeras O. Review article: bone transplantation and immune response. J Orthop Surg. 2009;17(2):206–11 [Review].
Li ZJ, Lu CT, Feng ZQ, Zhao QT, Zhou ZY, Lai RF. Antigen-extracted xenogeneic cancellous bone graft with recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2 enhances bone regeneration in repair of mandibular defect in rabbits. Kaohsiung J Med Sci. 2015;31(1):18–25 [Research Support, Non-U S Gov't].
Griesemer A, Yamada K, Sykes M. Xenotransplantation: immunological hurdles and progress toward tolerance. Immunol Rev. 2014;258(1):241–58 [Research Support, N I H , Extramural Review].
Lin FH, Liao CJ, Chen KS, Sun JS. Preparation of a biphasic porous bioceramic by heating bovine cancellous bone with Na4P2O7.10H2O addition. Biomaterials. 1999;20(5):475–84.
Orr TE, Villars PA, Mitchell SL, Hsu HP, Spector M. Compressive properties of cancellous bone defects in a rabbit model treated with particles of natural bone mineral and synthetic hydroxyapatite. Biomaterials. 2001;22(14):1953–9 [Evaluation Studies Research Support, U S Gov’t, Non-P H S].
Goto T, Kojima T, Iijima T, Yokokura S, Kawano H, Yamamoto A, et al. Resorption of synthetic porous hydroxyapatite and replacement by newly formed bone. J Orthop Sci. 2001;6(5):444–7 [Case Reports].
Valentini P, Abensur D. Maxillary sinus floor elevation for implant placement with demineralized freeze-dried bone and bovine bone (Bio-Oss): a clinical study of 20 patients. Int J Periodontics Restorative Dent. 1997;17(3):232–41.
Galia CR, Macedo CA, Rosito R, Mello TM, Camargo LM, Moreira LF. In vitro and in vivo evaluation of lyophilized bovine bone biocompatibility. Clinics. 2008;63(6):801–6.
Li Y, Guo H, Han R, Yang H, Wang Y. Experimental study on repairing segmental bone defects by biphasic ceramic-like biologic bone. Chin J Reparative Reconstr Surg. 2009;23(5):607–11.
Zang JC, Xiu XG, Cao B. Heterogeneous ossification of two kinds of bionic biphasic ceramic-like biologic bones. J Clin Rehabil Tissue Eng Res. 2007;11(1):45–7.
Ma J, Ge J, Zhang S, Sun A, Shen J, Chen L, Wang K, Zou Y, et al. Time course of myocardial stromal cell-derived factor 1 expression and beneficial effects of intravenously administered bone marrow stem cells in rats with experimental myocardial infarction. Basic Res Cardiol. 2005;100(3):217–23.
Marquez-Curtis LA, Janowska-Wieczorek A. Enhancing the migration ability of mesenchymal stromal cells by targeting the SDF-1/CXCR4 axis. Biomed Res Int. 2013;2013:561098.
Kitaori T, Ito H, Schwarz EM, Tsutsumi R, Yoshitomi H, Oishi S, et al. Stromal cell-derived factor 1/CXCR4 signaling is critical for the recruitment of mesenchymal stem cells to the fracture site during skeletal repair in a mouse model. Arthritis Rheum. 2009;60(3):813–23 [Research Support, Non-U S Gov't].
Xiu XG, Yan lin LI, Ya nuo LI, Liu X, Huang H. The preparation and the biocompatibility of biphasic ceramic-like biologic bone. Acad J Kunming Med Coll. 2005;26(2):4.
Lane JM, Sandhu HS. Current approaches to experimental bone grafting. Orthop Clin North Am. 1987;18(2):213–25.
Dalvi P, Vandana K. Growing bone assessment made easy at chairside. J Dent Res Rev. 2016;3(2):79.
Egan KP, Brennan TA, Pignolo RJ. Bone histomorphometry using free and commonly available software. Histopathology. 2012;61(6):1168–73.
Carmagnola D, Abati S, Celestino S, Chiapasco M, Bosshardt D, Lang NP. Oral implants placed in bone defects treated with Bio-Oss, Ostim-Paste or PerioGlas: an experimental study in the rabbit tibiae. Clin Oral Implants Res. 2010;19(12):1246–53.
Kamitakahara M, Ohtsuki C, Miyazaki T. Review paper: behavior of ceramic biomaterials derived from tricalcium phosphate in physiological condition. J Biomater Appl. 2008;23(3):197–212.
Dehousse V, Garbacki N, Colige A, Evrard B. Development of pH-responsive nanocarriers using trimethylchitosans and methacrylic acid copolymer for siRNA delivery. Biomaterials. 2010;31(7):1839–49 [Research Support, Non-U S Gov't].
Lee JB, Park SJ, Kim HH, Kwon YS, Lee KW, Min KS. Physical properties and biological/odontogenic effects of an experimentally developed fast-setting α-tricalcium phosphate-based pulp capping material. Bmc Oral Health. 2014;14(1):87.
Falco ED, Porcelli D, Torella AR, Straino S, Iachininoto MG, Orlandi A, et al. SDF-1 involvement in endothelial phenotype and ischemia-induced recruitment of bone marrow progenitor cells. Blood. 2004;104(12):3472–82.
Jin Q, Giannobile WV. SDF-1 enhances wound healing of critical-sized calvarial defects beyond self-repair capacity. PLoS One. 2014;9(5):e97035.
Kim IS, Park JW, Kwon IC, Baik BS, Cho BC. Role of BMP, betaig-h3, and chitosan in early bony consolidation in distraction osteogenesis in a dog model. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2002;109(6):1966.
Ferracane JL, Cooper PR, Smith AJ. Can interaction of materials with the dentin-pulp complex contribute to dentin regeneration? Odontology. 2010;98(1):2–14.
KRAUS KH, KIRKER-HEAD C. Mesenchymal stem cells and bone regeneration. Vet Surg. 2006;35(3):232–42.
Bruder SP, Kurth AA, Shea M, Hayes WC, Jaiswal N, Kadiyala S. Bone regeneration by implantation of purified, culture-expanded human mesenchymal stem cells. J Orthop Res. 1998;16(2):155–62.
Undale AH, Westendorf JJ, Yaszemski MJ, Khosla S. Mesenchymal stem cells for bone repair and metabolic bone diseases. Mayo Clin Proc. 2009;84:893–902.
Zhou B, Han ZC, Poon M-C, Pu W. Mesenchymal stem/stromal cells (MSC) transfected with stromal derived factor 1 (SDF-1) for therapeutic neovascularization: enhancement of cell recruitment and entrapment. Med Hypotheses. 2007;68(6):1268–71 2007/01/01/.
The study was supported by the Yunnan Provincial Department of Science and Technology - Kunming Medical University Joint Research Project (grant number 2018FE001-030) and Yunnan Provincial Health and Family Planning Commission Sports Medicine Science Section Leadership Training Program (grant number D-201639).
Ethics approval and consent to participate
All animal experimental procedures in the present study were approved by the Ethics Committee of Kunming Medical University.
Consent for publication
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Wang, F., Yang, G., Xiao, Y. et al. Effect of SDF-1 with biphasic ceramic-like bone graft on the repair of rabbit radial defect. J Orthop Surg Res 14, 231 (2019). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13018-019-1277-8
- Stromal cell-derived factor-1
- Biphasic ceramic-like biological bone
- Bone defect
- Bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells
- Bone tissue engineering