Skip to main content

Table 1 Summary of agreement in radiographic assessments in proposed classification system

From: Proposal for a classification system of radiographic bone changes after cervical disc replacement

Variable

Agreement pairs

Total pairs

Overall agreement (%)

95% LB

95% UB

90% LB

90% UB

Superior vertebra bone loss—SA

219

375

58.4

51.5

82.7

53.5

80.0

Superior vertebra bone loss—SM

353

375

94.1

86.9

100.0

88.7

100.0

Superior vertebra bone loss—SP

297

375

79.2

70.4

95.5

72.4

92.9

Inferior vertebra bone loss—IA

229

375

61.1

52.5

86.1

54.9

83.1

Inferior vertebra bone loss—IM

355

375

94.7

86.9

100.0

88.4

100.0

Inferior vertebra bone loss—IP

350

375

93.3

85.1

100.0

86.7

100.0

Superior radiolucent line—SA

274

375

73.1

61.3

91.2

63.2

88.9

Superior radiolucent line—SM

302

375

80.5

69.9

95.2

71.7

93.9

Superior radiolucent line—SP

284

375

75.7

67.2

93.1

68.5

91.5

Inferior radiolucent line—IA

323

375

86.1

78.1

97.3

79.9

96.3

Inferior radiolucent line—IM

334

375

89.1

79.7

100.0

81.3

98.7

Inferior radiolucent line—IP

335

375

89.3

81.6

100.0

83.2

98.7

Progressive radiolucent line

311

375

82.9

74.4

96.5

75.9

95.3

Severity of bone loss

187

375

49.9

45.1

73.1

46.7

70.4

Progressive bone loss

245

370

66.2

59.7

87.7

62.0

83.7

Superior heterotopic bone formation—SA

317

375

84.5

75.7

96.5

77.9

94.8

Superior heterotopic bone formation—SP

282

375

75.2

66.9

91.5

69.5

90.1

Inferior heterotopic bone formation—IA

344

375

91.7

83.2

100.0

84.8

100.0

Inferior heterotopic bone formation—IP

335

375

89.3

81.3

98.7

82.9

98.7

Subsidence

291

355

82.0

73.1

94.9

75.1

93.7

Migration

325

360

90.3

83.2

100.0

85.1

97.9

Loss of core implant height

341

375

90.9

83.2

100.0

85.1

98.7

Olisthesis

270

375

72.0

64.8

91.7

65.9

89.7

  1. LB Lower bound of confidence interval; UB Upper bound of confidence interval