Table 4 Superior capsule reconstruction—included studies
Author and date | Design | Mean age | No. of shoulders at f/u—PROMs | Follow-up duration (months) | Study results pooled | Graft type used | Functional/PROMs outcomes measured |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Alarcon [55] | Case series | 61 | 31 | 24–51 | No | Fascia lata autograft | Constant |
Barth [56] | Cohort—SCR vs complete vs augmentation | 60 | 24 | 24–29 | Yes | LHB autograft | Constant, ASES, SST |
Burkhart [57] | Case series | 64 | 41 | 24–50 | Yes | Human dermal allograft | ASES, SSV |
Denard [58] | Case series | 62 | 59 | 12–29 | Yes | Human dermal allograft | ASES, SSV, |
Ferrando [59] | Case series | 65 | 52 | 34 | Yes | Porcine dermal xenograft | ASES, SSV |
Greiner [23] | Cohort–SCR vs PCR | 62.3 | 20 | 47–79 | No | Porcine dermal xenograft | Constant, DASH |
Kim [60] | Case series | 58 | 45 | 24–48 | No | LHB autograft | Constant, ASES |
Kocaoglu [61] | Cohort–SCR vs SCR and PCR | 63.7 | 26 | 18–40 | Yes | Fascia lata autograft | Constant, QuickDASH |
LaBelle [62] | Case series | 62.5 | 28 | 24–41 | Yes | Dermal allograft | SST, ASES |
Lacheta [63] | Case series | 56 | 21 | 24–36 | No | Human dermal allograft | ASES, QuickDASH |
Lee and Min [64] | Case series | 60.9 | 36 | 24.8 | No | Fascia lata autograft and dermal allograft | Constant, ASES |
Lim [65] | Case series | 65.3 | 31 | 12–24 | Yes | Fascia lata autograft | Constant, ASES |
Mihata [5] | Case series | 65.1 | 24 | 24–51 | Yes | Fascia lata autograft | ASES, JOA |
Okamura [66] | Cohort–SCR 1 layer graft vs 3 layers | 76 | 35 | 24–69 | No | Teflon graft | ASES |
Ohta [67] | Case series | 75.3 | 35 | 12–62 | Yes | Fascia lata autograft | UCLA, JOA |
Ozturk [68] | RCT–SCR vs LDTT | 62.8 | 20 | 31 | Yes | Fascia lata autograft | Constant, ASES |
Pashuck Pashuck 2020 | Case series | 58.9 | 14 | 23–25 | Yes | Human dermal allograft | ASES |
Pennington [70] | Case series | 59.4 | 88 | 16–28 | Yes | Human dermal allograft | ASES |
Polacek [71] | Case series | 60 | 20 | 12 | Yes | Porcine dermal xenograft | SPADI |
Polacek [72] | Case series | 61.3 | 24 | 12 | Yes | Fascia lata autograft | SPADI |
Takayama [73] | Cohort–SCR mini open vs arthroscopic | 69.7 | 46 | 24–66 | Yes | Fascia lata autograft | ASES |