Table 12 Graft interposition—included studies
Author and Date | No. of shoulders at f/u | Study results pooled | Outcomes measured | Pre-op scores (SD) | 12-month scores (SD) | 24-month scores (SD) | X-month scores—specified duration (SD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Audenaert [39] | 39 | No | Constant | 25.7 (n/r) | Â | 72.1 (n/r) | Â |
Badhe [40] | 10 | Yes | Constant | 41.5 (17.5) | 62.5 (14.2) |  | 62.2 (14.5)–36 m |
Bond [41] | 16 | Yes | Constant UCLA | 53.9 (10.6) 18.4 (4.2) | 84 (8.9) 30.4 (4.0) | Â | Â |
Dukan [42] | 23 | Yes | Constant | 34.7 (7.8) | Â | 78.3 (16.5) | Â |
Gupta [43] | 24 | No | Constant | 66.6 (n/r) | Â | 88.7 (17.7) | Â |
Gupta [44] | 27 | No | Constant | 62.7 (n/r) | Â | 91.8 (13.3) | Â |
Kim [45] | 24 | No | UCLA, ASES, SST | 17 (n/r) 50 (n/r) | Â | 30 (n/r) 83 (n/r) | Â |
Kokkalis [46] | 21 | Yes | ASES | 25.2 (6.78) | 74.4 (16.13) | 14 pts 24Â months (pre-op 25.5, 6.38) (72.4, 14.23) | Â |
Modi [47] | 61 | No | OSS | 26 median (n/r) | 42 median (n/r) | Â | Â |
Mori [31] | 48 | No | UCLA, Constant, ASES | 14.3 (2.9) 37.4 (8.1) 40.8 (13) | 28.6 (4.3) 73.6 (6.6) 84.9 (8.1) | Â | Â |
Nada [48] | 21 | No | Constant | 46.7 (n/r) |  |  | 36 months–84.5 (n/r) |
Pandey [33] | 13 | Yes | Constant, OSS | 41.2 (3.1) 14.9 (3.5) | Â | 83.9 (6) 43.9 (2.4) | Â |
Petrie [49] | 31 | No | OSS (old score) | 46.7 (n/r) | Â | 30.6 (n/r) | Â |
Rhee [50] | 31 | No | UCLA, Constant | 12.5 (n/r) 48.4 (n/r) | Â | 31.1 (n/r) 81.8 (n/r) | Â |
Rhee [51] | 24 | Yes | ASES, QuickDASH, | 45.4 (19.1) 50 (17.9) | 81.6 (17.6) 14.2 (20) | Â | Â |
Sano [52] | 14 | Yes | JOA | 54.6 (9.3) | 83.1 (7.5) | Â | Â |
Dimitrios [53] | 68 | Yes | Constant | 32.5 (8.74) | 88.7 (7.44) | Â | Â |
Wong [54] | 45 | No | UCLA | 18.4 (n/r) | Â | 27.5 (n/r) | Â |