Skip to main content

Table 2 Evaluation of the quality of studies with Downs and Black checklist

From: Return to sport after conservative versus surgical treatment for pubalgia in athletes: a systematic review

Study

Reporting

External validity

Internal validity

Power

Total

Classification

Harr et al. [20]

3

3

2

0

8

Poor

Holmich et al. [14]

6

3

10

1

20

Good

Weir et al. [16]

9

3

7

1

20

Good

Yousefzadeh et al. [17]

8

2

10

0

20

Good

Schoberl et al. [15]

7

3

10

1

21

Good

Yousefzadeh et al. [19]

8

2

10

0

21

Good

Gore et al. [18]

10

2

9

1

22

Good

Paajanen et al. [13]

9

3

11

1

25

Excellent

Sheen et al. [12]

10

3

11

1

25

Excellent

Mazbouh et al. [21]

6

2

3

0

11

Poor