Skip to main content

Table 2 Baseline self-report measures by appropriateness groups

From: Validation of a second-generation appropriateness classification system for total knee arthroplasty: a prospective cohort study

 

Appropriatea

N = 142

Uncertainb

N = 90

Inappropriatec

N = 50

p-value

 

Mean (SD)

Mean (SD)

Mean (SD)

 

WOMAC (range 0–100) (best to worst)

 Pain

65.8 (13.9)b,c

47.6 (13.1)a,c

29.8 (12.6)a,b

< 0.001

 Stiffness

63.6 (24.4)b,c

47.4 (20.1)a,c

33.2 (22.8)a,b

< 0.001

 Function

69.7 (14.1)b,c

50.9 (13.3)a,c

35.3 (15.2)a,b

< 0.001

SF12v1 (range 0–100) (worst to best)

 PCS

26.3 (6.1)c

28.3 (6.2)c

33.0 (8.5)a,b

< 0.001

 MCS

41.7 (14.9)b,c

48.0 (14.1)a

48.5 (13.9)a

0.002

KSS

 Satisfaction with: (range 0–8) (lowest to highest)

  Pain level while sitting*

2.6 (1.7)b,c

4.0 (2.1)a,c

4.7 (2.1)a,b

< 0.001

  Pain level while lying in bed*

2.9 (1.9)b,c

4.0 (2.0)a,c

5.0 (2.1)a,b

< 0.001

  Function while getting out of bed*

1.6 (1.4)b,c

2.2 (1.5)a,c

3.5 (2.0)a,b

< 0.001

  Function performing household duties*

1.5 (1.2)b,c

2.2 (1.4)a,c

3.3 (1.8)a,b

< 0.001

  Function performing leisure activities*

1.2 (1.4)c

1.7 (1.5)c

2.6 (2.0)a,b

< 0.001

  Total satisfaction score (range 0–40)

9.9 (5.2)b,c

14.1 (6.2)a,c

18.8 (7.1)a,b

< 0.001

  1. *Kruskal-Wallis
  2. Superscript letters indicate differences among the appropriateness categories (aappropriate, buncertain, cinappropriate) by means of the Scheffé test for multiple comparisons
  3. SD Standard deviation; WOMAC Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index; SF-12 Short-Form-12 Health Survey; PCS Physical Component Summary; MCS Mental Component Summary; KSS Knee Society Clinical Rating