Table 1 Demographics
From: Musculoskeletal symptoms in SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19) patients
Study (year) | No. of patients | Sex | Age (mean SD or median IQR) | Study design | Country |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Zheng et al. [8] | 99 | M 51 F 48 | 49.40 (SD 18.45) | Retrospective single center | China |
Lei et al. [9] | 34 | M 14 F 20 | 55 (43–63) | Retrospective single center | China |
Mo et al. [10] | 155 | M 86 F 69 | 54 (42–66) | Retrospective single center | China |
Qian et al. [11] | 91 | M 37 F 54 | 50 (54–80) | Retrospective multi-center | China |
Ma et al. [12] | 37 | M 20 F 17 | 62 (59–70) | Retrospective single center | China |
Jin et al. [13] | 651 | M 331 F 246 | 46.0 (32–60) | Retrospective multi-center | China |
Zheng et al. [14] | 161 | M 80 F 81 | 45.0 (33.5–57) | Retrospective single center | China |
Wang et al. [15] | 80 | M 31 F 49 | 39.0 (32–48.5) | Retrospective multi-center (electronic database) | China |
Chen et al. [16] | 203 | M 108 F 95 | 54.0 (20–91) | Retrospective single center | China |
Zhou et al. [17] | 21 | M 13 F 8 | 66.1 (SD 13.94) | Retrospective single center | China |
Lo et al. [18] | 10 | M 3 F 7 | 54 (27–64) | Retrospective single center | China |
Huang et al. [19] | 41 | M 30 F 11 | 49.0 (41.0–58.0) | Prospective multi-center (electronic database) | China |
Zhang et al. [20] | 645 | M 328 F 317 | 46.65 (SD 13.82) | Retrospective multi-center (electronic database) | China |
Chen et al. [21] | 249 | M 126 F 123 | 51.0 (36–64) | Retrospective single center | China |
Feng et al. [22] | 476 | M 271 F 205 | 53.0 (40–64) | Retrospective multi-center | China |
Chen et al. [23] | 274 | M 171 F 103 | 62.0 (44–70) | Retrospective single center | China |
Zhang et al. [24] | 140 | M 71 F 69 | 57.0 (25–87) | Retrospective multi-center | China |
Lian et al. [25] | 788 | M 407 F 381 | 41.15 (SD 11.38) | Retrospective multi-center (electronic database) | China |
Cai et al. [26] | 298 | M 145 F 153 | 47.5 (33–61) | Retrospective single center | China |
Wan et al. [27] | 135 | M 72 F 63 | 47.0 (36–55) | Retrospective single center | China |
Cao et al. [28] | 102 | M 53 F 49 | 54.0 (37–67) | Retrospective single center | China |
Wang et al. [29] | 339 | M 166 F 173 | 69.0 (65–76) | Retrospective single center | China |
Xu et al. [30] | 62 | M 36 F 27 | 41.0 (32–52) | Retrospective single center | China |
Zhou et al. [31] | 191 | M 119 F 72 | 56.0 (46–67) | Retrospective multi-center cohort study | China |
Wu et al. [32] | 201 | M 128 F 73 | 51.0 (43–60) | Retrospective single center cohort study | China |
Du et al. [33] | 85 | M 62 F 23 | 65.8 | Retrospective multi-center | China |
Wang et al. [34] | 69 | M 32 F 37 | 42.0 (35–62) | Retrospective single center | China |
Guan et al. [35] | 1099 | M 640 F 459 | 47.0 (35–58) | Retrospective multi-center | China |
Goyal et al. [36] | 393 | M 238 F 155 | 62.2 (49–74) | Retrospective multi-center | USA |
Zhang et al. [37] | 28 | M 17 F 11 | 65.0 (56–70) | Retrospective single center | China |
Chen et al. [38] | 118 | M 0 F 118 | 31.0 (28–34) | Retrospective single center | China |
Wang et al. [39] | 1012 | M 524 F 488 | 50.0 (39–58) | Retrospective multi-center | China |
Xia et al. [40] | 10 | M 6 F 4 | 56.5 | Retrospective single center | China |
Liang et al. [41] | 1590 | M 904 F 674 | 48.9 (SD 16.3) | Retrospective multi-center | China |
Dai et al. [42] | 234 | M 136 F 98 | 44.6 | Retrospective single center | China |
Li et al. [43] | 25 | M 12 F 13 | 45.6 | Retrospective single center | China |
Chu et al. [44] | 54 | M 36 F 18 | 39 | Retrospective single center | China |
Qi et al. [45] | 70 | M 39 F 31 | 39.5 | Retrospective multi-center | China |
Godaert et al. [46] | 17 | M 8 F 9 | 86.5 | Retrospective single center | France |
Ye et al. [47] | 5 | M 2 F 3 | 30.0 | Retrospective single center | China |
Huang et al. [48] | 22 | M 6 F 16 | 22.0 (16.0–23.0) | Retrospective single center | China |
Tian et al. [49] | 262 | M 127 F 135 | 47.5 | Retrospective single center | China |
Huang et al. [50] | 34 | M 14 F 20 | 56.2 | Retrospective single center | China |
Xia et al. [51] | 20 | M 13 F 7 | 1.5 | Retrospective single center | China |
Zhao et al. [52] | 101 | M 56 F 45 | 44.44 | Retrospective multi-center | China |
Xu et al. [53] | 51 | M 25 F 26 | 41.6 | Retrospective single center | China |
Li et al. [54] | 548 | M 279 F 269 | 60.0 (48–69) | Retrospective single center | China |
Xu et al. [55] | 90 | M 39 F 51 | 50.0 (18–86) | Retrospective single center | China |
Lei et al. [56] | 119 | M 77 F 42 | 49.0 (SD 13.6) | Retrospective multi-center | China |
Pung et al. [57] | 17 | M 7 F 10 | 40.0 | Retrospective single center | Singapore |
Xu et al. [71] | 50 | M 29 F 21 | 42.3 | Retrospective single center | China |
Escalera-Antezana et al. [58] | 12 | M 6 F 6 | 36.5 | Retrospective single center | Bolivia |
Lechien et al. [59] | 417 | M 154 F 263 | 36.9 (SD 11.4) | Retrospective multi-center | Europe |
Dong et al. [72] | 11 | M 5 F 6 | 40.3 | Retrospective single center | China |
Total: 54 | 12.046 | M 6427 (54%) F 5597 (46%) | 52.13 | Â | Â |