Skip to main content

Table 1 General characteristic of the included RCTs

From: Efficacy of balance training for hip fracture patients: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials

Author

Region

No. of patients (n)

Type of exercise

Control

Duration and frequency

Follow-up

Outcomes

Study

Binder 2004

USA

46/44

Phase 1: flexibility, balance, coordination, movement speed; phase 2: add progressive resistance training

Core exercise focused on flexibility

6 months (3 days a week)

6 months

3, 5, 6

RCT

Hauer 2002

Germany

15/13

Progressive functional training with walking, stepping, or balancing

Motor placebo activities (calisthenics games)

3 months (3 days a week)

3 months

1, 2, 3, 6, 7

RCT

Latham 2014

USA

120/112

Standing from a chair, climbing a step

Nutritional education

6 months (3 days a week)

9 months

1, 2, 4, 5, 7

RCT

Monticone 2018

Italy

26/26

Balance task-specific training while standing

Walking training and open kinetic chain exercise

3 weeks (3 days a week)

12 months

1, 2, 3, 4, 7

RCT

Moseley 2009

Australia

80/80

[Inpatient] Standing up, sitting down, tapping the foot, and stepping onto and off a block

Lower dose exercise (30 min/day)

4 months (14 days a week)

4 months

3, 4, 5

RCT

Peterson 2004

USA

38/32

With balance and gait training

Conventional physical therapy

2 months (2 days a week)

12 months

1, 2, 4, 6, 7

RCT

Sherrington 1997

Australia

20/20

Stepping exercise with weight-bearing exercise

No treatment

1 month (7 days a week)

1 month

1, 2, 4, 5, 7

RCT

Sherrington 2004

Australia

40/40

Sit-to-stand, lateral step-up, forward step-out-and-over, forward foot taps

Non-weight bearing exercise

4 months (NS)

4 months

1, 2, 3, 6, 7

RCT

Zheng 2010

China

60/60

With balance and gait training

No treatment

6 months (3 days a week)

6 months

 

RCT

  1. RCT randomized controlled trials. 1, overall function; 2, gait; 3, lower limb strength; 4, ADLs; 5, performance task scores; 7, HRQoL