Skip to main content

Table 3 Comparison of postoperative BMD ratios at 3 months between each group

From: Effect of bisphosphonates in preventing femoral periprosthetic bone resorption after primary cementless total hip arthroplasty: a meta-analysis

ROI

BMD ratios in the bisphosphonates group

BMD ratios in the control group

WMD

[95 % CI]

P of chi-square

I 2

Selected model

P for overall effect

1

97.556

90.840

6.364

2.122

10.606

0

92 %

Random-effect model

0.003

2

96.275

93.488

2.479

1.886

3.072

0.564

0 %

Fixed-effect model

<0.001

3

97.041

95.413

1.309

0.824

1.794

0.673

0 %

Fixed-effect model

<0.001

4

100.207

98.036

2.349

0.505

4.193

0.003

78 %

Random-effect model

0.013

5

97.528

97.172

−0.619

−1.120

−0.119

0.138

46 %

Fixed-effect model

0.015

6

95.641

92.724

2.177

1.598

2.756

0.552

0 %

Fixed-effect model

<0.001

7

91.099

84.457

6.634

0.655

12.612

0.001

95 %

Random-effect model

0.030