Skip to main content

Table 2 Details of intervention and outcome assessments

From: The efficacy of gait rehabilitations for the treatment of incomplete spinal cord injury: a systematic review and network meta-analysis

Author

Year

Intervention

n

Duration of intervention (weeks)

Time measured after end of training

Outcome—measurement

Hornby TG [31]

2005

1. CPT: overground gait training

10

8

2 weeks after training

Distance—6 MWT

2. TM: BWSTT (average speed 2 km/h)

10

3. RAGT: Lower exoskeleton (Lokomat) with BWS

10

Dobkin B [32]

2006

1. CPT: overground gait training

18

12

Immediately after training

WISCI

2. TM: BWSTT, stretching and gait training

27

Dobkin B [26]

2007

1. CPT: overground gait training

37

12

Immediately after training

Velocity—15 MWT

2. TM: BWSTT, stretching and gait training

34

Distance—6 MWT

Alexeeva N [24]

2011

1. CPT: overground gait training, balance, functional activity, stretching, strengthening and aerobic exercise

12

13

2 days after training

Velocity—10MWT

2. TM: BWSTT (BWS 30%)

9

Field-Fote EC [17]

2011

1. FES: FES on ankle dorsiflexor (common peroneal nerve), gait training (BWS 30%)

15

12

Immediately after training

Velocity—10MWT

2. TM: unilateral or bilateral manual assistance for stepping BWS30 percent

17

Distance—2 MWT

3. RAGT: lower exoskeleton, 100% guidance force to provide maximum assistance (BWS 30%)

14

4. FES + TM: FES on ankle dorsiflexor muscle (common peroneal nerve), BWSTT (BWS 30%)

18

Lucareli PR [28]

2011

1. CPT: overground gait training

12

12

N/A

Velocity—Motion analysis

2. TM: BWSTT (BWS 40%)

12

Distance—Motion analysis

Alcobendas-Maestro M [29]

2012

1. CPT: overground gait training

38

8

N/A

Velocity—10MWT

Distance—6MWT

WISCI

2. RAGT: lower exoskeleton (Lokomat) (BWS 60%)

37

Jaynie F [39]

2014

1. CPT: precision training

10

8

N/A

Velocity—10MWT

2. TM: BWSTT

10

WISCI

Kapadia N [27]

2014

1. CPT: overground gait training, resistance and aerobic exercise

7

16

Immediately after training

Velocity—10MWT

2. FES + TM: FES on quadriceps, hamstring, dorsiflexor, plantarflexor, BWSTT

14

Distance—6MWT

Labruyere R [38]

2014

1. CPT: strengthening exercise

9

4

Immediately after training

Velocity—10MWT

2. RAGT: lower exoskeleton (average speed 1.5–2 km/h)

9

WISCI

Esclarin-Ruz A [33]

2014

1. CPT: overground gait training

36

8

N/A

Velocity—10MWT

2. RAGT: lower exoskeleton (Lokomat) (BWS 60%)

36

Distance—6MWT

WISCI

Shin JC [35]

2014

1. CPT: physical therapy (Bobath principle)

26

4

Within 2 days

WISCI

2. RAGT: lower exoskeleton (Lokomat) (BWS 50%) (average speed fix 1.5 km/h)

27

Tang Q [30]

2014

1. CPT: strengthening exercise (ergo bike load 60 W/ pedaling rate of 45 rpm)

15

N/A

N/A

Velocity—10MWT

2. RAGT: lower exoskeleton 70% guidance force to provide assistance (Lokomat) (BWS 35%)(average speed 1.8 km\h)

15

SenthilvelkumarT [36]

2015

1. CPT: overground gait training (BWS 40%)

8

8

N/A

WISCI

2. TM: BWSTT

7

Lin HD [34]

2016

1. CPT: overground gait training

8

8

N/A

WISCI

2. RAGT: lower exoskeleton (A3)

8

Chang SH [25]

2018

1. CPT: overground gait training, stretching, strengthening, balance, standing, sit to stand, stair

3

3

Immediately after training

Velocity—10MWT

2. RAGT: lower exoskeleton (Ekso)

4

Distance—6MWT

Edwards DJ[37]

2022

1. CPT: overground gait training, mobility therapy

16

12

Immediately after training

Velocity—10MWT

2. RAGT: lower exoskeleton (Ekso)

9

Distance—6MWT

  1. CPT, conventional physical therapy, FES, functional electrical stimulation, TM, treadmill, RAGT, robotic-assisted gait training, FES + TM, functional electrical stimulation combined with treadmill, BWS, body weight support, BWSTT, body weight support treadmill training. WISCI, Walking Index for Spinal Cord Injury, 10MWT, 10-min walk test, 6MWT, 6-min walk test, N/A, not available