From: Systematic review: preoperative psychological factors and total hip arthroplasty outcomes
Risk of bias score | Author, year | n | Follow-up duration | Psychological variable(s) | Main conclusion(s) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Pain study conclusions | |||||
< 5 | Riediger [19] | 79 | 2 months | Depression, somatization | ↑ Depression/somatization associated with ↑ pain |
Tarakji [23] | 44 | 3,12 months | Depression | ↑ Depression associated with ↑ pain | |
5–7 | Brembo [7] | 223 | 3 months | Self-efficacy | ↓ Self-efficacy associated with ↑ pain |
Duivenvoorden [7] | 140 | 3,12 months | Depression/anxiety | ↑ Anxiety/depression associated with ↑ pain | |
Etcheson [8] | 93 | 48 h | Depression | ↑ Depression has no significant impact on pain | |
Hassett [10] | 862 | 3,6 months | Depression/anxiety | ↑ Anxiety/depression associated with ↑ pain | |
Lindner [13] | 44 | 6,12 weeks | Depression/anxiety | ↑ Anxiety associated with ↑ pain; ↑ Depression has no significant impact on pain | |
Mercurio [14] | 40 | 12 months | Depression/anxiety | ↑ Anxiety/depression ↑ pain | |
Pinto [16] | 64 | 48 h | Depression/anxiety, optimism | ↑ Anxiety/depression have no significant impact on pain; ↑ Optimism associated with ↓ pain | |
Quintana [17] | 788 | 6 months, 2 years | Mental health | ↓ Mental health associated with ↑ pain | |
Rolfson [20] | 6,158 | 1 year | Depression/anxiety | ↑ Anxiety/depression associated with ↑ pain | |
Singh [22] | 441 | 2 years | Pessimism | ↑ Pessimism has no significant impact on pain | |
Function study conclusions | |||||
< 5 | Badura-Brzoza [4] | 184 | 6 months | Depression/anxiety | ↑ Anxiety/depression have no significant impact on function |
Negrini [15] | 40 | 3,12 days | Depression/anxiety | ↑ Anxiety/depression have no significant impact on function | |
Riediger [19] | 79 | 2 months | Depression, somatization | ↑ Depression/somatization associated with ↓ function | |
Tarakji [23] | 44 | 3,12 months | Depression | ↑ Depression associated with ↓ function | |
5–7 | Benditz [5] | 50 | 1,5 weeks | Depression/anxiety | ↑ Anxiety/depression associated with ↓ function |
Brembo [6] | 223 | 3 months | Self-efficacy | ↓ Self-efficacy associated with ↓ function | |
Duivenvoorden [7] | 140 | 3,12 months | Depression/anxiety | ↑ Anxiety/depression associated with ↓ function | |
Galea [9] | 627 | 3 months, 1,7 years | Depression/anxiety | ↑ Anxiety/depression associated with ↓ function | |
Hossain [11] | 762 | 1,5 years | Distress | ↑ Distress associated with ↓ function | |
Lindner [13] | 44 | 6,12 weeks | Depression/anxiety | ↑ Anxiety associated with ↓ function; ↑ Depression has no significant impact on function | |
Quintana [17] | 788 | 6 months, 2 years | Mental health | ↓ Mental health associated with ↓ function | |
Salmon [21] | 102 | 1,6 months | Depression/anxiety | ↑ Anxiety associated with ↓ function | |
Singh [22] | 441 | 2 years | Pessimism | ↑ Pessimism associated with ↓ function | |
Trinh [24] | 48 | 1 year | Depression | ↑ Depression associated with ↓ function | |
pain and function study conclusions | |||||
5–7 | Jaiswal [12] | 677 | 1 year | Mental health | ↓ Mental health associated with ↓ function and ↑ pain |
other study conclusions | |||||
5–7 | Rasouli [18] | 964 | NR | Complications | ↑ Anxiety/depression associated with ↑ complications |