Skip to main content

Table 5 Change of scores among All-inside and transportal anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction based on scoring method and follow-up duration

From: Transportal versus all-inside techniques of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction: a systematic review

Scoring system

Technique

Change of score during follow-up

6 months

1 year

2 years

3–5 years

KOOS

AIT

+ 30.97 (14.02)

+ 28.1

+ 29.97 (22.71)

–

TP

+ 28.87 (15.3)

+ 20.68 (7.39)

+ 29.9 (8.05)

–

IKDC

AIT

+ 28.04 (16.42)

+ 40.58 (13.13)

+ 38.99 (14.41)

–

TP

+ 25.8 (16.49)

+ 34.47 (6.01)

+ 34.09 (15.39)

+ 24.28 (15.7)

KT-1000

AIT

− 5.5 (0.9)

− 4.34 (1.947)

− 3.94 (2.15)

–

TP

–

− 1.8 (4.41)

− 2.87 (3.5)

–

Lysholm

AIT

 

+ 31.49 (9.95)

+ 37.13 (10.48)

–

TP

 + 28 (10.83)

+ 28.76 (6.16)

+ 27.99 (18.46)

+ 19.44 (13.2)

VAS

AIT

–

− 5.54 (1.15)

− 3.56 (2.14)

–

TP

− 12.25(14.72)

–

− 3.3 (2.9)

–

Short form-12 scoring system

AIT

Physical: + 13.6 (3.69)

Mental: + 5.2 (9.22)

Physical: + 16.7 (6.61)

–

Mental: + 4.9 (9.33)

Physical + 16.47 (10.37)

Mental: + 44.26 (9.84)

TP

–

–

Physical: + 13.6 (11.66)

–

Mental: + 2.54

  1. AIT all-inside technique, TP transportal technique, KOOS knee injury and osteoarthritis outcome score, IKDC International Knee Documentation Committee Subjective Knee Form, KT-1000 the KT-1000 knee arthrometer, VAS visual analog scale