Skip to main content

Table 5 Synthesis of results

From: The relationship between thoracic kyphosis and age, and normative values across age groups: a systematic review of healthy adults

 

Sample size

Number of studies

Results

Publication bias

Inconsistency (-)

Imprecision (-)

Indirectness

Study limitations/quality

Effect size/dose response

Possible confounding/bias

Overall quality

Consistency (+)

Precision (+)

Correlation

Kyphosis and age

6793

30

Table 4

ND

(+)

All correlations had positive sign

T1–T12: p > 0.05 (−)

T2–T12: p > 0.05 (−)

T4–T12: p < 0.05 (+)

T5–T12: p < 0.05 (+)

None

(+)

9 HQ, 21 MQ

N/A

 

(+)(+)(+)

Moderate

Reference values

6793

30

Table 4

ND

(−)

Statistical significance was achieved in 6 out of 16 cases.

(−)

Ranges did not overlap in 2 out of 6 cases. The between-range difference was always smaller than the SEM.

None

(+)

9 HQ, 21 MQ

N/A

(+)

12 articles divided sample by age groups

(+)(+)

Low

Ethnic group differences

5788

25

Table 4

ND

(−)

Statistical significance was achieved in 6 out of 9 cases.

(−)

Ranges did not overlap in 2 out of 6 cases. In 1 of the 2 cases, the between-range difference was greater than the SEM.

None

(+)

8 HQ, 17 MQ

N/A

(+)

14 articles specified the ethnicity of their sample

(+)(+)

Low

Gender differences

3937

13

Table 4

ND

(+)

No between-group comparisons achieved statistical significance

(−)

None

(+)

3 HQ, 10 MQ

N/A

 

(+)(+)(+)

Moderate

  1. ND not detected, HQ high-quality, MQ moderate quality, N/A not applicable, T thoracic vertebra, SEM standard error of measurement