Skip to main content

Table 3 Survival analysis of circRNAs in osteosarcoma

From: Clinicopathologic significance and prognostic value of circRNAs in osteosarcoma: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Author

Year

CircRNA

Regulation pattern

Cutoff

Expression

Survival indicator

Survival analysis

Data availability

Follow-up (month)

Low

High

Ding

2020

circ_0005909

Upregulated

Median

27

27

OS

Univariate

K-M curve

60

Gao

2020

circ_0001721

Upregulated

Median

26

30

OS

Univariate

K-M curve (p)

60

Hu

2020

circLARP4

Downregulated

Median

36

36

DFS, OS

Univariate

K-M curve (p)

42

Ji

2020

circ_001621

Upregulated

NR

10

20

OS

Univariate

K-M curve (p)

60

Jiang

2020

circXPO1

Upregulated

Median

26

26

DFS, OS

Univariate

K-M curve (p)

60

Jiang

2021

circ_0000658

Downregulated

Median

30

30

OS

Univariate

K-M curve (p)

60

Jin

2019A

circ_0102049

Upregulated

Median

38

38

OS

Multivariate

Reported (HR)

60

Jin

2019B

circ_100876

Upregulated

Median

24

24

OS

Univariate

K-M curve (p)

60

Jin

2019C

circ_0002052

Downregulated

Median

23

23

OS

Multivariate

Reported (HR)

36

Lei

2020

circ_0003074

Upregulated

Median

36

24

PFS, OS

Univariate

K-M curve (p)

60

Li

2018

circ_0007534

Upregulated

Average

26

31

OS

Multivariate

Reported (HR)

60

Li

2019

circ_0001721

Upregulated

Average

24

28

OS

Multivariate

Reported (HR)

60

Li

2020A

circ_0000073

Upregulated

NR

NR

NR

OS

Univariate

No response

60

Li

2020B

circ 0003732

Upregulated

Median

23

23

OS

Univariate

K-M curve

55

Liu

2020

circ_100284

Upregulated

Median

26

26

OS

Univariate

K-M curve (HR)

125

Liu

2021A

circ_0105346

Upregulated

Median

20

20

OS

Univariate

K-M curve (p)

60

Liu

2021B

circMTO1

Downregulated

NR

32

38

OS

Univariate

K-M curve

60

Ma

2018

circHIPK3

Downregulated

Median

45

37

OS

Univariate

K-M curve

60

Mao

2021

circXPR1

Upregulated

Median

NR

NR

DFS, OS

Univariate

No response

60

Nie

2018

circNT5C2

Upregulated

Median

84

86

DFS, OS

Multivariate

Reported (HR)

60

Pan

2019

circMMP9

Upregulated

NR

27

24

OS

Univariate

K-M curve

60

Pan

2020

circ_103801

Upregulated

NR

18

25

OS

Univariate

K-M curve (p)

60

Qi

2018

circ_0000502

Upregulated

Median

29

34

OS

Multivariate

Reported (HR)

60

Wang

2019A

circ_0003998

Upregulated

NR

NR

NR

OS

Univariate

No response

60

Wang

2019B

circ_0002052

Downregulated

Average

27

33

OS

Multivariate

Reported (HR)

36

Wang

2019C

circ_0021347

Downregulated

NR

NR

NR

OS

Univariate

No response

40

Wang

2020A

circCNST

Upregulated

NR

104

22

OS

Multivariate

Reported (HR)

200

Wei

2021

circ_0081001

Upregulated

Median

31

32

OS

Univariate

K-M curve (p)

60

Wen

2021

circHIPK3

Upregulated

NR

6

6

OS

Univariate

K-M curve (p)

48

Wu

2020

circ_0002052

Downregulated

NR

NR

NR

PFS, OS

Univariate

No response

60

Xiang

2020

circ_0005721

Upregulated

Median

25

25

DFS, OS

Multivariate

K-M curve (HR)

60

Yan

2020

circPVT1

Upregulated

NR

24

24

OS

Univariate

K-M curve (p)

60

Yang

2020

circ_0001105

Upregulated

NR

63

57

DFS, OS

Multivariate

Reported (HR)

60

Zhang

2017

circUBAP2

Upregulated

Median

NR

NR

OS

Univariate

No response

60

Zhang

2019

circ_0051079

Upregulated

NR

NR

NR

OS

Univariate

No response

96

Zhang

2020A

circ_0002052

Upregulated

Median

20

20

OS

Univariate

K-M curve (p)

60

Zhang

2020B

circ_0136666

Upregulated

NR

25

22

OS

Univariate

K-M curve

60

Zhao

2019

circSAMD4A

Upregulated

NR

NR

NR

OS

Univariate

No response

47

Zheng

2019

circLRP6

Upregulated

NR

NR

NR

DFS, OS

Univariate

Reported (HR)

125

Zhou

2017

circ_0008717

Upregulated

ROC

NR

NR

PFS, OS

Multivariate

Reported (HR)

80

Zhu

2018A

circPVT1

Upregulated

Average

50

30

OS

Univariate

K-M curve (p)

60

Zhu

2018B

circ_0081001

Upregulated

Average

55

27

OS

Multivariate

K-M curve (HR)

60

Zhu

2018C

circ_0004674

Upregulated

Average

37

23

OS

Univariate

K-M curve (p)

60

Zhu

2019

circ_0000885

Upregulated

Median

25

25

DFS, OS

Multivariate

K-M curve (HR)

60

  1. DFS disease-free survival, K-M curve Kaplan-Meier curve, NA not applicable, NR not reported, OS overall survival, PFS progression-free survival, ROC receiver operation curve analysis