Table 3 The range of wrist motion, grip strength, and clinical results
Measure | Group (n) | First follow-up (8 weeks) | Last follow-up |
|---|---|---|---|
Mean±sd (95% CI) | Mean±sd (95% CI) | ||
Extension (%) | S-PCP (16) | 35.44±7.76 (31.30 to 39.57) | 89.94±5.21* (87.16 to 92.71) |
M-PCP (19) | 33.05±9.19 (28.93 to 38.57) | 82.58±11.19*% (77.18 to 87.97) | |
M (14) | 36.64±8.58 (31.69 to 41.60) | 82.29±13.02* (74.77 to 89.80) | |
Flexion (%) | S-PCP (16) | 35.44±6.97 (31.73 to 39.14) | 89.38±7.37* (85.44 to 92.30) |
M-PCP (19) | 33.11±7.95 (29.27 to 36.94) | 83.89±10.69* (78.74 to 89.05) | |
M (14) | 36.36±8.44 (31.49 to 41.23) | 82.50±13.29* (74.82 to 90.18) | |
Radial deviation (%) | S-PCP (16) | 33.13±7.17 (29.30 to 36.95) | 90.69±6.01* (87.56 to 93.06) |
M-PCP (19) | 29.11±10.31 (24.13 to 34.07) | 83.26±9.07*% (78.56 to 87.50) | |
M (14) | 33.64±6.49 (29.90 to 37.39) | 83.57±13.74* (75.64 to 91.50) | |
Ulnar deviation (%) | S-PCP (16) | 34.25±7.13 (30.45 to 38.05) | 89.81±5.82* (86.71 to 92.91) |
M-PCP (19) | 30.74±7.46 (27.14 to 34.33) | 83.95±8.52* (79.84 to 88.05) | |
M (14) | 32.50±7.12 (28.39 to 36.61) | 82.79±12.72*% (75.44 to 90.13) | |
Grip strength (%) | S-PCP (16) | 37.88±6.81 (34.25 to 41.50) | 92.50±5.59* (89.52 to 95.48) |
M-PCP (19) | 33.11±9.77 (28.79 to 38.96) | 85.89±8.53*△ (81.78 to 90.00) | |
M (14) | 34.64±5.87 (31.25 to 38.04) | 86.29±10.21*△ (80.39 to 92.18) | |
Pronation (%) | S-PCP (16) | 32.63±6.48 (29.17 to 36.08) | 90.50±6.04* (87.28 to 93.72) |
M-PCP (19) | 32.32±8.49 (27.90 to 37.48) | 84.74±7.99*△ (80.88 to 88.59) | |
M (14) | 31.86±5.39 (28.74 to 34.97) | 84.35±8.47*△ (79.46 to 89.25) | |
Supination (%) | S-PCP (16) | 32.25±8.10 (27.94 to 36.56) | 90.25±5.87* (87.12 to 93.37) |
M-PCP (19) | 29.89±9.12 (25.49 to 34.29) | 82.11±8.54*% (77.99 to 86.22) | |
M (14) | 32.64±7.62 (28.24 to 37.04) | 83.71±11.07* (77.32 to 90.11) | |
VAS score | S-PCP (16) | 3.31±0.95 (2.81 to 3.82) | 0.11±0.60* (0.00 to 0.63) |
M-PCP (19) | 3.16±1.07 (2.64 to 3.67) | 0.68±0.75* (0.32 to 1.05) | |
M (14) | 2.93±0.92 (2.40 to 3.46) | 0.57±0.85* (0.08 to 1.06) | |
Modified Mayo wrist score | S-PCP (16) | 25.94±4.91 (23.45 to 28.55) | 90.94±4.17* (88.71 to 93.16) |
M-PCP (19) | 19.74±8.89% (15.45 to 24.02) | 79.21±15.39*% (71.79 to 86.63) | |
M (14) | 28.21±6.96 (24.19 to 32.23) | 78.93±12.12*% (71.93 to 85.92) | |
QuickDASH score | S-PCP (16) | 50.42±6.22 (47.11 to 53.74) | 2.70±3.64* (0.76 to 4.64) |
M-PCP (19) | 54.55±9.09 (50.16 to 58.93) | 7.54±8.02* (3.67 to 11.40) | |
M (14) | 49.35±7.69 (44.91 to 53.79) | 8.93±7.80*% (4.43 to 13.43) |