Skip to main content

Table 3 Changes (journey) and final scores (destination) in self-report measures at 6 months by appropriateness groups

From: Validation of a second-generation appropriateness classification system for total knee arthroplasty: a prospective cohort study

 

Changes (journey)

Final scores at 6 months, destination

 

Appropriatea

N = 142

Uncertainb

N = 90

Inappropriatec

N = 50

p-value

Appropriate

N = 142

Uncertain

N = 90

Inappropriate

N = 50

p-value

 

Mean (SD)

Mean (SD)

Mean (SD)

 

Mean (SD)

Mean (SD)

Mean (SD)

 

WOMAC (range 0–100) (best to worst)

 Pain

43.2 (21.6)b,c

26.4 (18.1)a,c

12.8 (17.8)a,b

< 0.001

22.7 (17.1)

21.2 (16.5)

17.0 (15.1)

0.11

 Stiffness

36.6 (32.5)b,c

24.7 (25.3)a,b

11.5 (25.9)a,b

< 0.001

26.9 (20.4)

22.6 (19.7)

21.7 (15.5)

0.14

 Function

42.3 (22.5)b,c

26.8 (17.7)a,c

13.7 (18.5)a,b

< 0.001

27.3 (18.6)

24.1 (17.7)

21.5 (15.6)

0.11

SF12v1 (range 0–100) (worst to best)

 PCS

14.0 (12.4)

13.3 (11.9)

9.3 (11.5)

0.10

40.0 (11.0)

41.6 (11.2)

42.5 (10.8)

0.33

 MCS

6.1 (14.9)c

2.0 (14.6)

−0.1 (13.5)a

0.03

48.1 (11.6)

49.9 (9.8)

46.5 (13.1)

0.25

KSS

 Satisfaction with: (range 0–8) (lowest to highest)

  Pain level while sitting*

3.5 (2.5)b,c

2.0 (2.5)a

1.6 (2.6)a

< 0.001

6.1 (1.9)

6.0 (1.9)

6.3 (1.8)

0.74

  Pain level while lying in bed*

3.3 (2.5)b,c

2.2 (2.6)a

1.5 (2.7)a

< 0.001

6.2 (2.1)

6.1 (2.0)

6.4 (1.6)

0.58

  Function while getting out of bed*

4.2 (2.4)c

3.4 (2.4)

2.4 (2.7)a

< 0.001

5.8 ()2.0

5.7 (2.0)

5.9 (1.7)

0.80

  Function performing household duties*

3.9 (2.4)c

3.4 (2.1)

2.4 (2.6)a

0.001

5.5 (2.0)

5.6 (1.9)

5.8 (1.9)

0.74

  Function performing leisure activities*

4.1 (2.2)c

3.7 (2.1)c

2.6 (2.6)a,b

0.001

5.3 (2.1)

5.4 (2.1)

5.3 (2.1)

0.88

  Total satisfaction score (range 0–40)

19.0 (10.2)b,c

14.8 (9.5)a

10.4 (10.9)a

< 0.001

28.9 (9.3)

28.7 (9.2)

29.4 (8.1)

0.91

  1. *Kruskal-Wallis
  2. Superscript letters indicate statistically significant differences among the three appropriateness categories (aappropriate, buncertain, cinappropriate) by means of the Scheffé test for multiple comparisons
  3. SD Standard deviation; WOMAC Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index; SF-12 Short-Form-12 Health Survey; PCS Physical Component Summary; MCS Mental Component Summary; KSS Knee Society Clinical Rating