Primary ACL reconstruction (n = 1014) | ACL revision (n = 1014) | Change from primary ACL reconstruction to revision | p value | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Preoperative KOOS | ||||
Pain | 75.2 (17.9) 77.8 (0.0; 100.0) n = 853 | 76.1 (19.2) 80.6 (11.1; 100.0) n = 898 | 1.3 (18.8) 0.0 (− 83.3; 66.7) n = 754 | 0.017 |
Symptoms | 69.7 (18.3) 71.4 (3.6; 100.0) n = 852 | 70.9 (19.3) 71.4 (10.7; 100.0) n = 898 | 1.7 (20.7) 0.0 (− 75.0; 67.9) n = 753 | 0.032 |
ADL | 84.9 (16.7) 91.2 (0.0; 100.0) n = 853 | 85.0 (17.5) 92.7 (2.9; 100.0) n = 897 | 0.2 (17.5) 0.000 (− 94.1; 61.8) n = 753 | 0.37 |
Sports and recreation | 42.2 (28.0) 40.0 (0.0; 100.0) n = 853 | 45.4 (29.9) 45.0 (0.0; 100.0) n = 898 | 3.7 (30.7) 0.0 (− 75.0; 100.0) n = 754 | 0.002 |
QoL | 34.3 (19.7) 31.3 (0.0; 100.0) n = 853 | 34.9 (24.0) 31.3 (0.0; 100.0) n = 898 | 1.4 (25.0) 0.0 (− 81.3; 100.0) n = 754 | 0.86 |
KOOS4 | 55.3 (17.7) 55.7 (0.9; 100.0) n = 853 | 56.8 (20.4) 56.5 (7.9; 100.0) n = 898 | 2.0 (19.7) 1.9 (− 59.4; 61.5) n = 754 | 0.012 |
One−year postoperative KOOS | ||||
Pain | 79.9 (18.7) 86.1 (5.6; 100.0) n = 613 | 78.2 (20.6) 84.7 (5.6; 100.0) n = 482 | − 3.1 (20.1) − 2.8 (− 63.9; 91.7) n = 303 | 0.003 |
Symptoms | 72.8 (19.6) 75.0 (14.3; 100.0) n = 612 | 71.1 (21.1) 75.0 (3.6; 100.0) n = 482 | − 2.8 (20.1) 0.0 (− 64.3; 60.7) n = 302 | 0.014 |
ADL | 88.0 (16.3) 94.1 (11.8; 100.0) n = 612 | 86.6 (18.3) 94.1 (2.9; 100.0) n = 482 | − 2.6 (16.1) 0.0 (− 61.8; 57.4) n = 302 | 0.006 |
Sports and recreation | 56.0 (31.0) 60.0 (0.0; 100.0) n = 613 | 51.9 (30.3) 52.5 (0.0; 100.0) n = 482 | − 5.2 (32.2) − 5.0 (− 95.0; 100.0) n = 303 | 0.002 |
QoL | 46.8 (28.2) 43.8 (0.0; 100.0) n = 613 | 45.8 (26.2) 43.8 (0.0; 100.0) n = 482 | − 1.8 (29.3) 0.0 (− 81.3; 93.8) n = 303 | 0.17 |
KOOS4 | 63.8 (22.2) 66.9 (7.9; 100.0) n = 613 | 61.7 (22.4) 64.6 (3.7; 100.0) n = 482 | − 3.2 (22.3) − 3.2 (− 59.8; 62.3) n = 303 | 0.01 |
KOOS change preoperative to one−year follow up | ||||
Pain | 5.8 (17.6) 5.6 (− 55.6; 66.7) n = 452 | 2.8 (19.7) 2.8 (− 75.0; 72.2) n = 366 | − 3.2 (28.2) − 2.8 (− 77.8; 94.5) n = 201 | 0.033 |
Symptoms | 4.3 (19.6) 3.6 (− 78.6; 60.7) n = 451 | 0.6 (20.6) 0.0 (− 89.3; 89.3) n = 366 | − 4.5 (.)(− 82.1; 121.4) n = 200 | 0.011 |
ADL | 3.7 (15.9) 1.5 (− 55.9; 61.8) n = 451 | 2.1 (15.6) 0.0 (− 54.4; 55.9) n = 365 | − 0.6 (22.7) − 1.5 (− 57.4; 97.1) n = 200 | 0.088 |
Sports and recreation | 16.4 (31.3) 15.0 (− 85.0; 100.0) n = 452 | 8.1 (32.7) 5.0 (− 100.0; 100.0) n = 366 | − 7.1 (46.9) − 10.0 (− 115.0; 130.0) n = 201 | 0.024 |
QoL | 15.6 (28.4) 12.5 (− 100.0; 87.5) n = 452 | 12.1 (29.9) 12.5 (− 100.0; 93.8) n = 366 | − 3.8 (44.5) − 6.3 (− 137.5; 125.0) n = 201 | 0.26 |
KOOS4 | 10.5 (20.6) 11.3 (− 71.8; 69.9) n = 452 | 5.9 (22.5) 5.9 (− 91.1; 71.4) n = 366 | − 4.6 (32.00) − 4.2 (− 79.2; 99.3) n = 201 | 0.028 |