Table 5 Comparison of studies on the outcomes of FAI surgery in non-athletic adults after 2007 and with a mean follow-up for at least 36 months
Author (year) | Surgery | No. of hips | FAI type | Mean follow-up (months) | Outcomes | THA or revision |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Beaulé et al. (2007) [13] | SDH | 37 | Cam | 37.2 | WOMAC: 61.2 to 81.4 | – |
Graves et al. (2009) [11] | SDH | 48 | Cam and pincer | 38 | Merle d’Aubigné: 13 to 16.8 | – |
Naal et al. (2012) [25] | SDH | 233 | Cam and pincer | 60.7 | 83% returned normal hip function | 11.6% |
Boone (2012) [30] | SDH | 22 | Cam and pincer | 46.8 | 50% clinical failure | 27% |
Steppacher et al. (2015) [10] | SDH | 93 | Cam and pincer | 131 | Merle d’Aubigné: 15.3 to 16.9 | 11.8% |
Peters et al. (2015) [1] | SDH | 142 | Cam and pincer | 36 | Risk factor: age and pre-op HHS | 32% |
Horisberger et al. (2010) [3] | Arthroscope | 20 | Cam and pincer | 36 | NASH: 47.15 to 78.3 | 40% |
Palmer et al. (2012) [4] | Arthroscope | 201 | Cam | 46 | NASH: 56.1 to 78.2 | 13% |
Malviya et al. (2012) [15] | Arthroscope | 612 | Cam and pincer | 38.4 | Quality of life scores improved 76.6% of patients, and 9% deteriorated | – |
Larson et al. (2012) [31] | Arthroscope | 94 | Cam and pincer | 42 | HHS: 64.5 to 94.3 (labral re-fix) and 64.7 to 84.9 (labral excision) | 8.5% |
Skendzel et al. (2014) [32] | Arthroscope | 466 | Cam and pincer | 73 | Outcomes better in preserved joint space group than limited joint space group | 25.1% |
Hufeland et al. (2016) [33] | Arthroscope | 44 | Mainly cam | 66.3 | HHS: 67.2 to 86.4 | 11.4 |
Menge et al. (2017) [29] | Arthroscope | 145 | Cam and pincer | 120 | No influence on outcomes for labral debridement or repair | 34% |
Our study | Mini-open and arthroscope | 39 | Cam | 44 | HHS: 61.1 to 84.2 | 23% |