An enhanced recovery after surgery program in orthopedic surgery: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Hu, Zhi-Chao; He, Lin-Jie; Chen, Dong; Li, Xiao-Bin; Feng, Zhen-Hua; Fu, Cheng-Wei; Xuan, Jiang-Wei; Ni, Wen-Fei; Wu, Ai-Min

doi:10.1186/s13018-019-1116-y

Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research

Table 1 The characteristics of the included studies

From: An enhanced recovery after surgery program in orthopedic surgery: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Source	Country	Surgical site	Intervention	No. of participants	Age, mean (SD)	Male/female
Auyong et al. [29]	USA	Joint	ERAS	126	66.2 (10.2)	44/82
Auyong et al. [29]	USA	Joint	Traditional care	126	68.44 (9.98)	41/85
Christelis et al. [32]	Australia	Joint	ERAS	297	67 (10)	113/184
Christelis et al. [32]	Australia	Joint	Traditional care	412	68 (11)	164/248
den Hertog et al. [33]	Germany	Joint	ERAS	74	66.58 (8.21)	23/51
den Hertog et al. [33]	Germany	Joint	Traditional care	73	68.25 (7.91)	20/53
Maempel et al. [34]	England	Joint	ERAS	84	69.8 (8.9)	42/42
Maempel et al. [34]	England	Joint	Traditional care	81	70.1 (10.5)	40/44
Malviya et al. [35]	England	Joint	ERAS	1500	68	711/789
Malviya et al. [35]	England	Joint	Traditional care	3000	69	1482/1518
McDonald et al. [36]	England	Joint	ERAS	1081	69 (11)	439/642
McDonald et al. [36]	England	Joint	Traditional care	735	70 (13)	307/428
Stambough et al. [42]	USA	Joint	ERAS	488	55 (19)	247/241
Stambough et al. [42]	USA	Joint	Traditional care	281	59 (16)	126/155
Stowers et al. [37]	New Zealand	Joint	ERAS	100	66.7 (9.2)	47/53
Stowers et al. [37]	New Zealand	Joint	Traditional care	100	65.4 (12.5)	41/59
Khan et al. [43]	England	Joint	ERAS	3000	68 (10)	1390/1610
Khan et al. [43]	England	Joint	Traditional care	3000	69 (10)	1482/1518
Pedersen et al. [38]	Denmark	Fracture	ERAS	178	82.2	42/136
Pedersen et al. [38]	Denmark	Fracture	Traditional care	357	82.6	85/272
Eriksson et al. [24]	Sweden	Fracture	ERAS	80	85	65/15
Eriksson et al. [24]	Sweden	Fracture	Traditional care	335	82	227/108
Liu et al. [41]	USA	Fracture	ERAS	2514	79.7 (11.7)	NA
Liu et al. [41]	USA	Fracture	Traditional care	2488	79.3 (11.9)	NA
Macfie et al. [39]	England	Fracture	ERAS	117	82.5 (9.2)	89/28
Macfie et al. [39]	England	Fracture	Traditional care	115	82.7 (8.7)	91/24
Wang et al. [8, 40]	USA	Spine	ERAS	38	65 (11)	17/21
Wang et al. [8, 40]	USA	Spine	Traditional care	15	59 (12)	10/5
Nazarenko et al. [44]	Russia	Spine	ERAS	23	44.3	NA
Nazarenko et al. [44]	Russia	Spine	Traditional care	25	42.2	NA

ERAS enhanced recovery after surgery, SD standard deviation

Back to article page

ISSN: 1749-799X

Contact us

Submission enquiries: journalsubmissions@springernature.com