Skip to main content

Table 1 Strain on the anterior, middle, and posterior parts of the medial tibial plateau in all the groups under different loading conditions at different flexion angles during human cadaver testing (\( \overline{x} \)±s, με)

From: The biomechanical and histological effects of posterior cruciate ligament rupture on the medial tibial plateau

Flexion angles

Parts

Groups

200 N

400 N

600 N

800 N

1000 N

Anterior

PCL intact group

−17.25 ± 1.71

−33.50 ± 2.24

−48.67 ± 2.90

−60.17 ± 4.15

−78.50 ± 4.01

ALB rupture group

−18.17 ± 1.94

−34.17 ± 3.43

−66.67 ± 2.88*

−86.33 ± 3.93*

−109.17 ± 4.26*

PMB rupture group

−25.50 ± 2.43*, **

−45.33 ± 2.66*, **

−65.67 ± 3.14*

−85.00 ± 5.33*

−110.67 ± 3.62*

PCL rupture group

−26.17 ± 1.40*, **

−45.58 ± 2.91*, **

−68.08 ± 1.98*

−87.17 ± 4.49*

−112.67 ± 4.14*

Middle

PCL intact group

−12.42 ± 1.44

−21.17 ± 1.85

−32.42 ± 3.06

−43.83 ± 3.54

−54.75 ± 4.27

ALB rupture group

−12.83 ± 1.72

−21.83 ± 2.14

−42.83 ± 3.19*

−59.50 ± 3.73*

−73.50 ± 3.94*

PMB rupture group

−17.00 ± 1.90*, **

−27.83 ± 1.72*, **

−42.33 ± 3.56*

−59.17 ± 4.71*

−73.83 ± 3.25*

PCL rupture group

−17.33 ± 1.72*, **

−28.25 ± 2.30*, **

−44.08 ± 3.32*

−61.50 ± 4.58*

−75.67 ± 4.54*

Posterior

PCL intact group

−6.17 ± 1.34

−10.50 ± 2.11

−15.17 ± 1.90

−20.33 ± 3.03

−25.50 ± 3.34

ALB rupture group

−5.50 ± 1.05

−9.67 ± 1.63

−7.83 ± 2.79*

−9.50 ± 3.56*

−13.67 ± 3.72*

PMB rupture group

−2.83 ± 2.23*, **

−4.83 ± 1.84*, **

−7.17 ± 2.14*

−9.0 ± 3.16*

−12.33 ± 3.50*

PCL rupture group

−2.42 ± 1.88*, **

−4.67 ± 2.02*, **

−6.17 ± 3.41*

−9.33 ± 3.06*

−11.33 ± 3.23*

30°

Anterior

PCL intact group

−5.33 ± 2.15

−10.42 ± 2.39

−15.50 ± 3.18

−21.08 ± 3.68

−26.75 ± 4.96

ALB rupture group

−5.83 ± 1.17

−11.50 ± 3.39

−36.17 ± 3.55*

−47.67 ± 4.18*

−60.00 ± 4.56*

PMB rupture group

−5.67 ± 1.97

−10.83 ± 2.56

−17.33 ± 3.83**

−21.67 ± 4.80**

−28.83 ± 5.88**

PCL rupture group

−14.08 ± 1.73*, **, ***

−25.50 ± 3.03*, **, ***

−38.42 ± 3.42*, ***

−49.00 ± 4.51*, ***

−61.75 ± 5.15*, ***

Middle

PCL intact group

−23.25 ± 2.01

−39.33 ± 3.11a

−57.92 ± 4.94

−77.83 ± 3.13

−97.08 ± 4.68

ALB rupture group

−23.83 ± 2.14

−41.17 ± 3.87a

−82.33 ± 4.80*

−104.83 ± 4.26*

−126.83 ± 5.08*

PMB rupture group

−23.33 ± 1.97

−40.17 ± 3.19a

−59.67 ± 5.61**

−79.00 ± 4.94**

−98.50 ± 5.47**

PCL rupture group

−31.17 ± 2.41*, **, ***

−56.58 ± 2.47*, **, ***, a

−84.25 ± 4.58*, ***

−108.50 ± 4.54*, ***

−127.83 ± 5.65*, ***

Posterior

PCL intact group

−12.50 ± 2.24

−23.00 ± 3.33

−34.25 ± 3.42

−41.67 ± 4.60

−48.33 ± 4.48

ALB rupture group

−11.00 ± 2.37

−20.67 ± 3.08

−19.83 ± 3.55*

−23.50 ± 4.09*

−29.67 ± 5.85*

PMB rupture group

−11.83 ± 2.14

−20.67 ± 3.14

−33.50 ± 3.62**

−40.00 ± 4.56**

−46.50 ± 5.82**

PCL rupture group

−6.67 ± 2.02*, **, ***

−12.58 ± 2.75*, **, ***

−17.83 ± 3.56*, ***

−22.58 ± 3.20*, ***

−27.33 ± 5.05*, ***

60°

Anterior

PCL intact group

8.75 ± 1.77

17.50 ± 2.88

25.00 ± 3.67

31.75 ± 4.16

37.17 ± 4.06

ALB rupture group

7.33 ± 1.97

16.50 ± 2.51

10.83 ± 3.82*

15.00 ± 4.94*

17.83 ± 4.83*

PMB rupture group

8.00 ± 1.41

16.83 ± 2.48

23.50 ± 3.62**

31.00 ± 3.90**

36.50 ± 3.56**

PCL rupture group

3.33 ± 1.50*, **, ***

5.92 ± 2.31*, **, ***

8.83 ± 3.16*, ***

13.67 ± 4.25*, ***

16.42 ± 4.32*, ***

Middle

PCL intact group

−25.50 ± 2.39

−43.00 ± 3.02

−64.83 ± 3.46

−83.50 ± 5.28a

−108.67 ± 5.40

ALB rupture group

−26.00 ± 2.28

−44.50 ± 2.81

−86.17 ± 3.60*

−114.33 ± 5.61*, a

−141.50 ± 5.72*

PMB rupture group

−25.67 ± 2.34

−43.67 ± 2.25

−66.50 ± 5.21**

−85.83 ± 6.91**, a

−110.00 ± 5.40**

PCL rupture group

−34.75 ± 1.87*, **, ***

−59.33 ± 3.09*, **, ***

−87.58 ± 3.50*, ***

−116.33 ± 4.01*, ***, a

−144.08 ± 5.37*, ***

Posterior

PCL intact group

−24.75 ± 3.11

−41.58 ± 5.09

−62.17 ± 6.09

−82.92 ± 8.04a

−105.42 ± 6.65

ALB rupture group

−23.00 ± 3.41

−39.33 ± 5.47

−34.83 ± 7.25*

−41.33 ± 5.20*, a

−48.17 ± 10.76*

PMB rupture group

−23.67 ± 3.08

−40.50 ± 4.59

−60.50 ± 5.09**

−79.67 ± 5.20**, a

−103.50 ± 9.79**

PCL rupture group

−11.75 ± 4.03*, **, ***

−23.33 ± 3.99*, **, ***

−33.17 ± 6.97*, ***

−40.08 ± 5.99*, ***, a

−46.42 ± 9.32*, ***

90°

Anterior

PCL intact group

11.33 ± 2.46

20.67 ± 4.25a

30.00 ± 3.30a

38.25 ± 4.16

46.17 ± 3.46

ALB rupture group

9.50 ± 2.51

19.00 ± 2.97a

12.50 ± 3.94*, a

18.33 ± 3.01*

23.50 ± 5.21*

PMB rupture group

11.00 ± 1.55

20.00 ± 3.41a

28.50 ± 3.94**, a

37.83 ± 3.60**

44.17 ± 3.66**

PCL rupture group

4.42 ± 1.51*, **, ***

8.50 ± 2.94*, **, ***, a

11.33 ± 2.46*, ***, a

17.58 ± 4.44*, ***

20.75 ± 4.14*, ***

Middle

PCL intact group

−23.25 ± 2.77

−41.42 ± 3.32

−60.92 ± 4.32

−85.58 ± 4.25

−102.42 ± 6.74

ALB rupture group

−25.17 ± 3.25

−42.67 ± 3.45

−84.83 ± 5.08*

−115.17 ± 4.88*

−146.67 ± 7.97*

PMB rupture group

−24.50 ± 2.59

−42.17 ± 3.19

−61.67 ± 4.59**

−87.50 ± 5.47**

−104.33 ± 8.80**

PCL rupture group

−34.25 ± 2.34*, **, ***

−57.58 ± 2.23*, **, ***

−86.33 ± 4.31*, ***

−116.42 ± 4.50*, ***

−148.67 ± 6.36*, ***

Posterior

PCL intact group

−36.58 ± 3.75

−64.83 ± 4.39

−95.42 ± 5.87

−125.33 ± 4.83

−153.67 ± 7.58a

ALB rupture group

−35.17 ± 3.19

−62.00 ± 4.60

−69.50 ± 6.86*

−91.67 ± 4.68*

−116.67 ± 11.99*, a

PMB rupture group

−34.00 ± 3.41

−61.83 ± 4.62

−92.83 ± 5.98**

−123.17 ± 4.02**

−150.67 ± 8.50**, a

PCL rupture group

−25.58 ± 2.94*, **, ***

−44.00 ± 3.72*, **, ***

−66.50 ± 6.90*, ***

−90.92 ± 5.27*, ***

−112.25 ± 8.34*, ***, a

  1. PCL posterior cruciate ligament, ALB anterolateral band, PMB posteromedial band
  2. *P < 0.05 compared with PCL intact; **P < 0.05 compared with ALB rupture; ***P < 0.05 compared with PMB rupture
  3. aDunnett T3 test; others, SNK-q test