Skip to main content

Table 1 Patient demographics and fracture characteristics

From: Outcomes and complication rates of different bone grafting modalities in long bone fracture nonunions: a retrospective cohort study in 182 patients

Variable

Overall

Autograft

Allograft

Autograft/allograft

rhBMP-2

Gender

     

Male

102 (56%)

58 (55%)*

16 (42%)

4 (25%)

7 (30%)

Female

80 (44%)

47 (45%)*

22 (58%)

12 (75%)

16 (70%)

Mean age (years)

44 (±13.6)

41 (±12.5)*

47 (±13)

46 (±14)

52 (±15)

EtOH

     

Abuse

44 (24%)

22 (21%)

8 (21%)

0

5 (22%)

Occasionally

45 (25%)

30 (29%)

12 (32%)

6 (37%)

6 (26%)

Never

97 (51%)

53 (50%)

18 (47%)

10 (63%)

12 (52%)

Tobacco smoking

     

Current

68 (37%)

41 (39%)

16 (42%)

4 (25%)

6 (26%)

Former

30 (17%)

17 (16%)

4 (11%)

4 (25%)

5 (22%)

Never

84 (46%)

47 (45%)

18 (47%)

8 (50%)

12 (52%)

Illicit drug use

     

Current

28 (15%)

17 (16%)

9 (24%)

0**

1 (4%)

Former

7 (4%)

6 (6%)

0

0**

1 (4%)

Never

147 (81%)

82 (78%)

29 (76%)

16 (100%)

21 (92%)

Injury mechanism

     

MVA/MCA

83 (46%)

49 (47%)

18 (47%)

8 (50%)

8 (35%)

Fall

39 (21%)

20 (19%)

10 (26%)

3 (19%)

6 (26%)

GSF

6 (3%)

5 (4%)

1 (3%)

0

0

Other

33 (18%)

31 (30%)

9 (24%)

5 (31%)

9 (39%)

Fracture location

     

Tibia

98 (54%)

57 (54%)

21 (55%)

9 (56%)

11 (48%)

Femur

46 (25%)

28 (27%)

9 (24%)

4 (25%)

5 (22%)

Humerus

38 (21%)

20 (19%)

8 (21%)

3 (19%)

7 (30%)

Fracture characteristics

     

Open

79 (43%)

51 (49%)

17 (45%)

4 (25%)

7 (30%)

Closed

103 (57%)

54 (51%)

21 (55%)

12 (75%)

16 (70%)

  1. MVA motor vehicle accident, MCA motorcycle accident, GSF gunshot fracture, rhBMP-2 recombinant human bone morphogenetic protein-2.
  2. *(P < 0.05), statistically significant difference among autograft cohort vs. allograft, autograft/allograft, and BMP-2 cohorts.
  3. ** (P < 0.05) statistically significant difference between autograft/allograft group and remaining cohorts.